Marek Edelman - Post-doctoral thesis (123/145)

3,251 views · Published 11 September 2017 · 5:43 · Indexed 28 October 2026

Channel: Web of Stories - Life Stories of Remarkable People · 2017 · News & Politics

Watch on YouTube

To listen to more of Marek Edelman’s stories, go to the playlist: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wpEJsJK7ur8&list=PLVV0r6CmEsFy9YZLKSE0bbnuUJfcOBFxQ

Marek Edelman (1919-2009) was the last surviving leader of the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising. He had remained in Poland following the Nazi defeat and was active in domestic and international politics while at the same time becoming one of Poland’s leading cardiologists. [Listeners: Anka Grupinska, Joanna Klara Agnieszka Zuchowska, Joanna Szczesna; date recorded: 2003]

TRANSCRIPT: Ah, before that I had my post-doctoral thesis.

[L] 19th March 1967, I remember.

Because you're a...

[L] in Kraków.

... slave!

[Q] You presented your post-doctoral thesis about "Some of the mechanisms involved in pulmonary oedema". It always makes me think of 'The movement of celestial bodies' because it's such a nice, neat title.

Yes, that's it with some, that's what it depends on. So one day, once there was a bit of freedom following 1956, Jakubowski said: 'Lads - you've got to do your PhDs, otherwise they'll kick you out.' So I said: 'PhD? Why a PhD?' Three or four people did their PhDs within a month, including me after which Jakubowski says, 'You'll present your thesis at the cardiology conference.' This conference was full of big-wigs - Biernacki, my God, the people who were there! The entire medical world. Biernacki says: 'You know he says, 'I can't understand a thing' so I said to Biernacki, 'That's because you're too stupid.' I went down, and the chairman of this conference was this young man, I went down to Biernacki, 'You misunderstood, I speak so simply, I use the language of the marketplace.' To which he says, 'I understood but I understood everything, which means it's worthless.'

[L] I don't recall the title of your doctoral thesis.

I don't remember the title but the subject was 'Treating circulatory insufficiency with intravenous steroids'. At the time, this was revolutionary. The chairman said that this kind, it was his luck to get them, he said, this kind of presentation wouldn't be allowed at cardiology conferences. And Biernacki said, 'I understood this and that's terrible when you understand everything straight away, it can't be any good.' After that, they told me to do a post-doctoral thesis. I don't know what the mechanism is behind pulmonary oedema, to this day it's not clear, this whole mechanism of acute circulatory insufficiency. So I came up with the idea... it was always said that it was caused by too much blood reaching the lungs whereas I came up with the idea that it wasn't because there was too much but rather not enough. I'm not going to go into the details of this. And Jakubowski said, 'You know, you'll never be able to do this here because the anti-Semites won't let you. Go to Kraków.' So I went to Kowalczykowa, she looked at my histopathology specimens and said, this is amazing but that's how it is. And that's how I had my post-doctorate in Kraków.

[L] Your wife spent that entire time standing in a church.

She wasn't standing, she was sitting down because her joints were aching.

[L] I didn't know the details.

I had 99 votes out of 100. Of course, they played a trick on me because they'd told me before what questions they were going to test me on, but then they got mixed up and began to question me about something completely different. Jakubowski asked me, 'Why chest pain disappears in cases of circulatory insufficiency?' You have to be raving mad to ask a question like that, but it was a post-doctoral thesis so I had to say something, I was coming back with some answer when an old professor of physiopathology spoke up and said, 'The candidate is right, please don't interrupt him!' And so I passed my post-doctorate but because the times had changed in Kraków, they didn't send it to Warsaw then, and when they did send it, it was already 1968.

[L] So that was that.

That was that. They summoned all of the reviewers, Kowalczykowa, Falkiewicz, I don't remember any more who the others were, but there was this army professor who said, 'I contest.' So they asked him why. 'Because I contest.' So they said, 'On what grounds?' 'I don't need to tell you.' And that's how it ended. That was it. But it was a great idea to talk about pulmonary oedema because the Japanese had been the first to get hold of this idea, after which it was presented in Polish scientific literature as something ordinary, but no one knows who came up with this notion although that doesn't really matter as long as it's widely read.

More from this channel