THE SECRET BEHIND OLD MacDONALD'S FARM / SHOULD HUMANS EAT MEAT (FLESH)?

3,169 views · Published 9 April 2018 · 1:15:38 · Indexed 4 November 2026

Channel: Priest Isaac · 2018 · Education

Watch on YouTube

http://www.radioanu.com/
Call/Whatsapp: 1-268-728-3162
email: [email protected]

A similar version of this song called “Ohio (Old Macdougal Had a Farm) was first published in Tommy’s Tune collection, a compilation of songs dating back to the WWI era published in 1917. Some other different versions of the song were recorded even earlier than Tommy’s Tune book. Still it seems that this one is referred as first appropriate recorded variant.

An even older version of this song was discovered in 1908 in England, in “Workhouse Marylebone” a rest home in London”. The song was sung by an old lady, Mrs. Goodey and published in Cecil Sharp’s Collection of English Folk Songs.

The oldest known melody with an appropriate theme dating back to around 1719 is an opera piece, “The Kingdom of the Birds”, found in Thomas D’Urfey’s songs collection “Wit and Mirth: Or Pills to Purge Melancholy”

More from this channel