DALEEL with SP SINGH - On dera, Gurmeet Ram Rahim, Panchkula killings, Rape case
1,660 views · Published 31 August 2017 · 49:38 · Indexed 29 October 2026
Channel: PTC NEWS · 2017 · News & Politics
As saner voices make a comeback after the shrill cacophony over a rapist godman, the death of 38 people in police/army firing, many of them in the lush green suburbs of Panchkula where respectable citizens will take their morning walks and their kids will play along the manicured roads that were punctuated with corpses of people now termed as goons or worse, we need to engage with the phenomenon of these cults and sects called deras. Their relationship to the state, what they mean to their disciples and what it says about the social, economic & political milieu we live in. On the panel: 1. M. Rajiv Lochan Professor of Contemporary History, who has done much research into the dera culture in Punjab, Haryana and elsewhere in the region 2. Sudesh Kumari Activist-Lawyer, Jan Sangharsh Manch, was among the first who approached the victim sadhvi in Kurukshetra and waged a long drawn battle to press for the CBI probe which finally led to the rapist being convicted and jailed 3. Sumail Singh Sidhu Historian-Activist who has been engaging with the issue for long 4. Dr Megha Singh Political Analyst & Commentator, author and formerly a senior journalist How does one understand what at the outset seems like "whacky spiritualism," but which, to the hooked devout, offers "something very real and very positive." Dr Lochan describes deras as constructs that offer dignity, social support, medical help, and food security to the followers, precisely the things that the modern Indian state refuses or fails to offer to vast sections. Much of the educated middle class often merely shrugs its shoulders and sneers at these solace-seeking hordes, unable to understand the strands connecting believers with the dera. These bonds are multifarious, visible, and tenacious; and often stronger than the bonds with the uncaring, distant, and seemingly unjust, Indian state. What is baffling is the dichotomy of the Indian State which is unable to assert authority in routine but one fine day flexes enough muscle to assert authority, even by killing in daylight a couple of scores of people, right outside the beautiful houses inhabited by peace-loving citizens. A judiciary that flails at the margins even as people die of hunger, lack of treatment, or farmers commit suicide as a staple reaction to messed up agriculture policy formulation, or young and old are killed in road accidents because someone did not do proper road safety engineering, or kids die in hospital for lack of oxygen, steps up to unleash the state's guns against the unwashed, unruly crowds as it pulls out all stops to maintain peace. And then the citizenry, the media and many other organs chirp in unison to hail the judiciary for its courage in sending to jail a baba who was in cahoots with the powers that be for a long time. Someone forgets to question the judicial process in which a rape case as serious as this takes 15 years and more than 200 sittings of the court to reach a conclusion. Clearly, the authority of the state is exercised only when it is politically convenient for those currently in power to do so. But is there a class character to this exercise of authority? This episode of Daleel was first telecast on August 30, 2017. Feedback, suggestions welcome at [email protected]. Also, please help spread the word about DALEEL, an effort at cerebral television in times of dumbing down of the news media. Thank you for watching. DALEEL WITH SP SINGH is now telecast every Wednesday at 8 pm on PTC News. It is often telecast again at 2 pm on Thursday. Please check listings as TV channels often change schedules without notice. So, check out the time, and since it may still change, do not bet your money on it. http://www.ptcnews.tv/ http://www.facebook.com/ptcnewsindia PTC News , Punjabi News,Punjab Latest News,Latest News from Punjab,Punjab News Headlines,Top News from Punjab
More from this channel
-
0:18
Sadi kheti , agriculture show on PTC News
-
1:30
Rakkhan Puniya - SAD
-
0:41
MANDI revised
-
9:21
PS EP 174 2
-
10:31
straight talk harsimrat kaur badal sig_01.mpg
-
11:53
straight talk harsimrat kaur badal sig 02
-
11:07
straight talk harsimrat kaur badal sig 03
-
8:50
straight talk harsimrat kaur badal sig 04