Pinker 2 - Taboo Issues

329 views · Published 12 January 2014 · 1:58 · Indexed 30 October 2026

Channel: Nick Michelioudakis · 2014 · Education

Watch on YouTube

Why is it that certain topics are 'off limits'? Why is it that, in certain circles, it is a crime to even contemplate something? Pinker proposes that this may be a practice which, while adaptive in one-to-one relationships, is maladaptive when it is carried over in groups. The thing is that certain words / phrases / beliefs / practices function as 'shibboleths' or 'identity badges'; they show the other group members that you are one of them. And here is the interesting bit: the same is true of words / phrases / beliefs or practices that the group is against. According to some fundamentalists, you cannot be a communist and espouse trade-unionism; you cannot be a feminist and say 'vive la difference'... An infamous example of what might happen if someone violates a taboo was the case of the great E. O. Wilson. When back in the 1970s he dared to suggest that biology and evolutionary theory had a great deal to say on social organisation, the response by some was rabid. He was slandered, heckled and attacked both verbally and physically... (for a serious discussion of the arguments, see 'The Sociobiology Debate' -- OUP).

[NB: I do not own the copyright to this video clip. I have uploaded it here for educational purposes].

More from this channel