News13 Investigates: Unsafe Fixes
626 views · Published 23 March 2016 · 4:18 · Indexed 8 November 2026
Channel: WLOS News 13 · 2016 · News & Politics
ASHEVILLE, N.C. -- It only takes one garage cutting corners to put any one of us on the road at risk. Being an informed consumer and knowing what to look for is your best defense. "The muffler is actually shoved back and touching the plastic splash shield. Well, that's a fire hazard," Brian Allen of Pack Brothers Collision Center explained. "As a father, that infuriates me. That really ticks me off. I would use some choice words, but I won't." As an expert witness in mechanics, Allen understands the danger better than most. "When I am sitting in court, I think about my kids," Allen said. "What I would do if it were my kids?" "It's got a buckle right here right where the seat belt is, right where the airbag is, and who sits right in those seats? That is where my son sits. My daughter sits on the other side," Allen said. Mechanics were supposed to replace the bumper reinforcement and the muffler. "So had we not done an inspection on this vehicle, all you would have seen was the pretty plastic cover on the bumper and the consumer would have never known," Allen said. That despite the insurance company paying for new parts. "As you can see it is still damaged, it was not replaced, and that is a huge safety issue," Allen said. A simple experiment shows why. Take an aluminum can, whole. It holds a lot of weight before it collapses. But if the can is damaged with a simple dent, even a little weight can compromise the integrity, causing it to collapse. Cars are engineered to collapse and crumple in very specific ways--for your family's safety. "The damage went in about a good foot and a half in the frame rail, and no one did anything to correct it. So if it gets hit again from behind, how far is that damage going to travel now?" Allen asked. Fixes like this put those riding in the car at risk, and mechanics call it fraud. "That's the body shop stealing those parts. They stole from the insurance company. They stole from the owner here," Allen said. "I started a campaign seven years ago to get shops licensed," Billy Walkowiak of Collision Safety Consultants explained. "I have talked to the House of Representatives, senators." "You or myself tomorrow, with no expertise whatsoever, you could open a body shop tomorrow," Walkowiak continued. In North Carolina, it's become a pass-the-buck situation. "Most of them want to put it off on the Department of Insurance, the Department of Insurance wants to put it off on the Attorney General," Walkowiak said. News 13 ran into the same when reaching out to the Attorney General's office, which sent us to the Department of Insurance. Commissioner Wayne Goodwin put it back on the legislature. So, the consumer must he their own advocate. Ask to see the parts your mechanic replaced and take a close look at the seams between panels. They should be even. "Those are telltale signs that something might be wrong with the alignment of the body panel. It could mean that you have uni-body damage or frame," Allen said. The week News 13 spoke with Pack Brothers Collision Center, they had nine attorneys that had reached out to them to prove shops had engaged in unfair or deceptive trade practices as a result of unsafe repairs. When we reached out to several local representatives in the state legislature, they claimed there's never been a real push in the state to license repair shops. It's legal action that can be a customer's only recourse to make it right. North Carolina recently had its largest judgment against a body shop and insurance provider who should have totaled a Land Rover with structural damage. After seeing the evidence, the jury ruled that the vehicle should have been replaced. _______________ Follow WLOS on social media: WLOS ABC 13 News on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/News13/ WLOS ABC 13 News on Twitter: https://twitter.com/WLOS_13 WLOS ABC 13 News on Instagram: https://instagram.com/wlos_13 Subscribe to WLOS on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/user/ABC13Channel/?sub_confirmation=1 Listen to AnchorMOMS, the Podcast: https://wlos.com/news/anchormoms/anchormoms-the-podcast Watch more top local news stories: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kk8Ge6UXHJs&list=PLkVbaoT-aYbIvnEpR0Ct5QQQqYaORUSUH For all of the day’s top local and national news, visit http://www.wlos.com Watch our live newscasts and other live video at https://wlos.com/watch Have a news tip? Send it directly to us: Email us: [email protected] Call the Newsroom: 828.684.1340 WLOS ABC 13 News serves the Asheville, NC area and the rest of western North Carolina and Upstate South Carolina. We keep our audience informed through local news, weather forecasts, traffic updates, notices of community events, sports and entertainment programming since 1954.