D&D Adventurers Just Wanna Murder Hobo EVERYTHING!- GM 911

3,424 views · Published 7 November 2017 · 10:41 · Indexed 6 November 2026

Channel: Nerdarchy · 2017 · Gaming

Watch on YouTube

Nerdarchy the News Letter- http://nerdarchynewsletter.gr8.com/
Fearless Adventurers Just Wanna Murder Hobo EVERYTHING in D&D!- GM 911
Original GM 911 Post
I am a long time D&D 2e, 3e player, and I started a Pathfinder game about 10 months ago for mixed members of my family (teens and adults, males and females).  They all have various video game and board game experience, and they all have a solid intelligence level.

My problem is, they refuse to run away, no matter how bad the odds, and 99/100 combat rounds, they simply attack or cast their most damaging spell on the nearest/biggest enemy.  After the first few months, they were able to wrap their heads around the game rules, and I have implemented several strategies against them (reach weapons, archers with cover, spell combinations, invisible attackers) to devastating effect.  The group was large at 6 players, so I found I needed my villains to have an edge to be a threat to the party (especially with the healing domain cleric spamming heals).

The times I have given the PCs challenges to overcome that penalize their methods (high AC, DR, SR, elemental resistance, etc.), they tend to rely on the dice and the healing to pull them through, simply accepting the poor damage output, and keeping the finger on the trigger. I had to fudge some dice and make some home rules just to keep them from dying in several tough encounters. I was trying to keep from killing my players’ first characters, since I was hoping to start a new game once everyone was acclimated to the rules and world.  We are about to start the new game with one less player, (5) and they don’t have a dedicated healer this time, so I am worried about their survival.

I even went so far as to create a new skill, Knowledge: tactics, that a few players took, in order to give the players my advice or tips on how to solve some problems, but they would either opt not to make the roll when I asked, or mostly ignore the advice.

To summarize, how do I help my players use some strategy to stay alive and help keep the encounters fresh?  Or should I just be setting up simple pins for them to knock down, since they keep showing up every week anyway? Does strategy take a long time to cultivate, or do I need to kill off a few characters to make them less headstrong?

Thanks for everything you guys do!

Matt V.
Please Like, Comment, Share and Subscribe!
Help Support Nerdarchy by Shopping at YOUR Favorites Places
on the Internet. Just use these links and shop as usual. Nothing changes for you-
Amazon- http://amzn.to/2jf0boA

Nerdarchy the Store- https://goo.gl/M4YZEQ

Drive Thru RPG- https://goo.gl/6nf5zh

Easy Roller Dice- https://goo.gl/1n0M1r

D&D and Think Geek Gear- https://goo.gl/LZAV5z

Find Us-

Patreon:  https://www.patreon.com/Nerdarchy

Website:  https://www.Nerdarchy.com

Facebook:  https://www.facebook.com/Nerdarchy

Instagram:  https://www.instagram.com/Nerdarchy/

Twitter: https://www.twitter.com/Nerdarchy

SnapChat: https://www.snapchat.com/add/Nerdarchy

Pinterest:  https://www.pinterest.com/Nerdarchy/

Tumblr:  http://www.Nerdarchy-blog.tumblr.com/
Music By- www.soundcloud.com/zerofluxboundary

More from this channel