DALEEL with SP SINGH, on our relationship with the Army, Major Nitin Gogoi, & the age of spectacle

374 views · Published 1 June 2017 · 46:37 · Indexed 14 November 2026

Channel: PTC NEWS · 2017 · News & Politics

Watch on YouTube

The Army always commanded a quiet respect in India, but now you have to shout your support. Our relationship with the armed forces is being mediated by those who claim ownership of the Army. Conversely, your right to that ownership is being obliterated.

On the panel:

1. Gobind Thukral
Veteran journalist, expert on South Asian affairs

2. Brigadier (Retd) Inderjit Singh Gakhal
Served in Kashmir, 3rd generation that served the armed forces

3. Bir Devinder Singh
Politician, former Deputy Speaker, Punjab Vidhan Sabha

4. Prof Mohd Khalid
Political Scientist, expert on Kashmir

We have all grown up with the notion that the army commands our respect. We have all shouted Jai Jawan slogans. We have always rooted for the soldier. We have always gone to the movies that show the bravery of soldiers. The olive green uniform has always commanded our spoken or unspoken, quiet, dignified respect.

Now, a new shouting brigade has cropped up which has become a mediator of our relationship with the armed forces.

Any criticism of Major Nitin Gogoi's action of tying up a man on the bonnet of an army vehicle and parading him through the streets can be seen as undue criticism of our armed forces. Any opposition of the army's decision to honour him with an award is seen as unpatriotic. Criticism of the army chief's statement that he wanted to fire into the crowds if only the crowd had guns and not stones is seen as support for Pakistan.

The entire civilian population's relationship with the Army is now being mediated through such uninformed, passionate, incendiary debates and arguments.

And nothing is being done to stop it.

In 1974, the Assistant Sec-Gen of the UN, Sean MacBride said, in his Nobel Lecture, "To the rights enshrined in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights one more might, with relevance, be added. It is 'The Right to Refuse to Kill.'

Imagine if a Kashmiri were to advocate this right and were to say to his fellow youth that they should refuse to join the militants or the Indian Army because there are bigger, better things to do in life than to kill people illegally (by joining the militancy) or to join a war machine that acts in the name of the country and law (by joining the Army).

He would be hounded by the militants and the law enforcement authorities, both.

Panelists on the debate said the country is being pushed into a permanent age of spectacle. The PM speaks to his people, unmediated. A number of army generals lined up on TV debates every night on various channels speak in sync with the ruling dispensation.

The argument that use of human shield will open the country to criticism in the international arena is turned on its head by saying this was an innovative way of dealing with the situation at hand.

An incumbent Chief Minister from the Congress writes an article asking for a distinguished services medal for the officer using a Kashmiri youth as a human shield. The government actually concedes that demand.

The age of spectacle!

If a large number of Kashmiri youth turn up for army recruitment test, it is projected as an argument against the dominant sentiment in the valley because it pitches those youth against Kashmiris, it pitches Army against Hurriyat's calls. It fits in with the age iof spectacle.

The Geneva convention clearly and unequivocally categorises the use of human shields as a “war crime”— no ifs or buts.

The debate engages with the issue as to why our armed forces, which have remained apolitical, non-partisan, all these decades, are being drawn into the murky waters of the country’s politics? 

With many serving and retired generals taking sharply partisan positions on public platforms, is that good for democracy? Is that good for the armed forces?

Wherever the military plays an active role in politics, it limits popular sovereignty, the core character of democracy.

This episode of Daleel was first telecast on May 31, 2017. Feedback, suggestions welcome at [email protected]. Also, please help spread the word about DALEEL, an effort at cerebral television in times of dumbing down of the news media.

Thank you for watching. DALEEL WITH SP SINGH is now telecast every Wednesday at 7 pm on PTC News. Please check listings for repeat telecast as TV channels often change schedules without notice. So, check out the time, and since it may still change, do not bet your money on it. 



http://www.ptcnews.tv/
http://www.facebook.com/ptcnewsindia

PTC News , Punjabi News,Punjab Latest News,Latest News from Punjab,Punjab News Headlines,Top News from Punjab

More from this channel