Daleel with SP Singh - On saffronisation of FTII, ICHR, ICSSR, NBT | July 22, 2015

554 views · Published 23 July 2015 · 43:35 · Indexed 31 October 2026

Channel: PTC NEWS · 2015 · News & Politics

Watch on YouTube

On the panel -
-- Prof Lallan Baghel, head of Political Science at PU
-- Dr HK Bali, leading cardiologists, currently with Fortis Hospital, Mohali and someone who is more aligned with the latest thinking in the Modi govt
-- Arjun Sheoran, lawyer-activist, People's Union of Civil Liberties
-- Harish Jain, publisher with massive footprint in the world of Punjabi publishing
As DALEEL WITH SP SINGH engages with the raging controversy over Gajendra 'Yudhishtra'  Chauhan's appointment as chairman of Film and Television Institute of India (FTII), anchor SP Singh attempts to widen the debate to a large number of academic and cultural bodies that have been seeing something similar, though not all instances made it to the TV studio debates.
Gajendra Chauhan of "700 TV serials" and "20 years with the BJP" fame had the misfortune of following men like Adoor Gopalakrishnan, Girish Karnad, Shyam Benegal, U.R. Ananthamurthy, and his immediate predecessor Saeed Akhtar Mirza, and took up a job that was in a way 'refused' to  Jahnu Barua, Santosh Sivan and Rajkumar Hirani. 

Since we know these names a lot more than we know of GC Pande and MGS Narayanan or S Settar (ex-chairmen of ICHR) or of Nanjundappa (ICSSR), Gajendra ended up in too many TV studios, perhaps for the first time. Even Mahabharta did not do this for him.

The verdict on his tenure, whether he quits today or spends years in the hot seat, is clear -- his work will not amount to any significant contribution to even qualify as a footnote or a passing reference in the history of Indian cinema and television.

The main issue is the agenda behind these appointments.

Panelists in DALEEL refer to Pahlaj Nihalani, appointed Censor Board chief, clearly because his work that the govt fell in love with was a six-minute campaign video -- for then PM-aspirant Modi, titled 'Har Ghar Modi'
 
While there are innumerable references in the debate to appointments to ICHR, ICSSR, NBT, IIMs and IITs, BHU etc, there are also serious questions raised about RSS weekly Organiser's allegations that said some IITs and IIMs are promoting anti-Indian and anti-Hindu sentiment, and singled out eminent nuclear scientist Anil Kakodkar

Also, the debate points out that Congress has been no less guilty of appointing people of a certain proclivity to top echelons of academia. Two Congress education ministers were seen as particularly culpable: Nurul Hasan and Arjun Singh. Both backed Marxist or socialist scholars, but perhaps they were intelligent enough to avoid light weights.

Arjun Sheoran said there was a reason NDA was appointing light weights. The feather weight category scholars can resist little when Nagpur wants things done. That's why they put Smriti Irani as the boss of all scholars, her Yale 'degree' notwithstanding.

DALEEL did not hesitate to question the silence in Punjab on the subject. How can the intellectuals speak up, asks a participant, when they all know that to become a professor or a vice chancellor, there are other routes that are open. Harish Jain has even more to add: he said they have no stake in the debate. "We do not have scholars of even a level who would be worried about how IIM or IITs are running or an ICHR or ICSSR is run. They are never going to be there."

Watch the debate. It's hot, gets a little noisy perhaps at times, but remains engaging. 
This episode of DALEEL with SP SINGH was telecast on PTC News on July 22, 2015. Feedback, suggestions welcome at [email protected]. Also, please help spread the word about DALEEL, an effort at cerebral television in times of dumbing down of the news media.

Thank you for watching. DALEEL WITH SP SINGH is telecast every Wednesday at 9 pm on PTC News.

More from this channel