Deputy Fired, Charged With DWI

2,769 views · Published 18 June 2013 · 4:49 · Indexed 26 October 2026

Channel: WLOS News 13 · 2013 · News & Politics

Watch on YouTube

The investigation continues into the suspicious circumstances surrounding the immediate firing of a Buncombe County Deputy. Lieutenant Jason Honeycutt is charged with DWI and fired from the department. 
But a closer look at incidents involving officers shows departments handle DWI cases differently, some even hiring officers with convictions. The law in North Carolina says departments have the right to hire officers with drunk driving convictions. 
Lt. Jason Honeycutt is just the latest officer fired from his job for DWI. 
James Holbert Jr. is a former highway patrolman. He was once the lead coordinator for the Toys For Tots Christmas program. His state career ended after a DWI in 2013. News 13 found six cases, all handled similarly with immediate firings or resignations, but for one. 
In June 2010, State Trooper Timothy Scott Stiwinter was charged with DWI and leaving the scene of an accident. Stiwinter refused the field sobriety test and immediately resigned after his arrest. Stiwinter was also placed on administrative duty in 2009 for an alleged domestic incident.
Trooper Jeff Bair in September 2011 was charged with DWI. His blood alcohol content tested at .08, which is right at the illegal limit. Bair resigned immediately after his arrest.
The former Henderson County Sheriff, who now serves as the director of the Association of Chiefs of Police feels standards for police conduct must be beyond reproach.
As Sheriff of Henderson County, I would not hire an officer to patrol Henderson County that had a DWI. They just would never be in a patrol car if they had ever been convicted of driving while impaired, said George Erwin. 
In June 2012 former Buncombe County deputy Jeremy Cabe, 31, resigned immediately after he was arrested for DWI. He had been with the department since 2005.In February 2013, State trooper James Holbert, Jr. was arrested for DWI. He was also a marine reservist who had been with the Highway department since 2007. He resigned the same day of his DWI charge.There are a number of studies that show there's a high rate of alcoholism among law enforcement, said Erwin. There's also a high rate of domestic violence within the law enforcement community. Law enforcement doesn't like to admit it but there is.Just two weeks ago, Woodfin Officer Michael Salley, 30, got a DWI. He blew a blood alcohol of .13. Salley is also charged with speeding. He has not resigned or have been fired. Sally remains suspended weeks after his arrest and his police chief has yet to comment on the status of an internal investigation into the arrest. Salley was named Officer of the year in Woodfin several years ago.While Salley may lose his job News 13 has spoken with several law enforcement leaders who know departments across North Carolina will hire officers convicted of DWI into their departments.Erwin, who was the former Sheriff of Henderson County said the following of such procedures.There would be officers who would apply to our department with DWI convictions who I would not hire to ever get in a squad car. But the next thing I knew another Sheriff's office or agency would hire them, said Erwin. It's just a decision of the executive officer.One big concern Erwin pointed out was problems with testimony in court coming from an officer convicted of a DWI. Erwin said the cross-examination by a defendant's attorney would likely turn to the officer's conviction if the patrolman himself had been convicted of DWI.
The latest DWI case remains former Buncombe County Lt. Jason Honeycutt. He was arrested Friday. The case remains under additional investigation with more information surrounding the circumstances of his arrest expected to come out. Erwin said citizens still need to remember one thing.There are hundreds of thousands of law enforcement officers every day, men and women risking there lives out there, that are doing the right thing. They are very responsible and are doing their jobs.Under North Carolina Training and Standards for police officers experts in law enforcement tell News 13 standard or threshold for officers criminally charged with DWI is not whether they are proven guilty but rather that the probability they committed a DWI is likely. Because of that threshold, chiefs or Sheriff's have the discretion to fire an officer charged with DWI but not yet convicted.News 13 is asking you to weigh in with your opinion on department procedures on News 13's Facebook page. Do you think patrol officers should be fired immediately after a DWI arrest or should they be allowed to be suspended pending an internal investigation or outcome of the court case. Go to WLOS Facebook and cast your vote and post your opinion.

* Photo of Michael Salley courtesy of the Weaverville Tribune. 

By Kimberly KingFollow Kim on Twitter @KimKingReports

Related Links:
Buncombe Deputy Arrested

More from this channel