DALEEL with SP SINGH - On Karnataka Natak, Threat to Constitution & What Democracy Means
231 views · Published 28 May 2018 · 46:29 · Indexed 10 November 2026
Channel: PTC NEWS · 2018 · News & Politics
Even as the Congress and Janata Dal (Secular) government taking over Karnataka is being interpreted as victory of democracy and Constitutional values, the villains of the opera have come from all hues. Elected state governments have been dismissed on flimsy grounds in the past by all dispensations, and the assault on the Constitution isn't a monopoly of any one side. Still, many argue that the decimation of institutional norms has assumed a degree that India has not seen so far. True, the Supreme Court's doors open at midnight; true, that the Modi-Amit Shah machine was halted in its game plan; true, that the Opposition put up a brave fight; but does that mean Constitution is safe now? On the panel: 1. Prof Ashutosh Kumar Political Scientist, who teaches Constitution 2. Rajiv Godara, Advocate Swaraj India 3. Vineet Joshi BJP 4. Arjun Sheoran, Advocate National Organising Secretart, PUCL Much of this debate should have dealt with substantive aspects of democracy along with its procedural aspects, but then Karnataka was too recent and dominated the discussion. The point is that successful democracy is a holistic idea; involving both aspects: Procedural and substantive. Procedural aspects include notions of political equality, effective institutions, free and fair elections, legislative assemblies and constitutional govts, good voter turn outs; etc, etc while substantive aspects include the socio-economic equality of citizens, tolerance, accountability of rulers, respect for rules, and a strong political engagement. Procedural democracy in India functions quite well. We have regular elections, there has been no military coup. There are Constitutionally mandated institutions of Supreme Court, High Courts and President. The Election Commission is fairly autonomous. The substantive democracy eludes us because promises have been seldom met. -- India’s rank on the Global Hunger Index is dismal. -- Public health is in a shambles – kids die because of lack of oxygen. -- We are systematically excluding poor from MNREGA -- Farmers are dying, forced to march for miles to make themselves heard. -- Discrimination, humiliation continue against Dalits who are attacked for keeping moustaches or watching a garba dance or for riding a horse. -- Meanwhile, the politician is not telling people that we can be great by making institutions and structures work. Instead, he evokes symbols, and plays the 'I am great' tune. -- There is a crisis of institutions and an overemphasis on leaders. Since India incessantly talks about Ambedkar, here's what he said: “In politics we will be recognising the principle of one man one vote and one vote one value. In our social and economic life, we continue to deny the principle of one man one value… If we continue to deny it for long, we will do so only by putting our political democracy in peril.” Now, the worry is that even the procedural aspects of democracy are weakening. Governors play the Centre's game as if neutrality is alien to them. The idea of free, ethical, and fair media is fast eroding. Media is losing credibilty and independence, and large sections have stopped questioning power. The January 12 presser by four SC judges will be remembered in history as the critical tipping point. Is the average Indian voter becoming apathetic or even actually wishful for a homogenous benevolent dictatorship model than a plural democracy? But then, how is the Constitution saved if the opposition to those abusing power is anchored in simple transactional deal? President K.R. Narayanan asked in his Golden Jubilee Speech in Parliament: “Is it the Constitution that has failed us, or have we failed the Constitution?” That's a question we need to engage with. This episode of Daleel was first telecast on May 27, 2018, Sunday. Feedback, suggestions welcome at [email protected]. Also, please help spread the word about DALEEL, an effort at cerebral television in times of dumbing down of the news media. Thank you for watching. DALEEL WITH SP SINGH is ordinarily telecast every Sunday at 8 pm on PTC News. The repeat telecast is at 2 pm the next day, Monday. Please check listings as TV channels often change schedules without notice. So, check out the time, and since it may still change, do not bet your money on it. http://www.ptcnews.tv/ http://www.facebook.com/ptcnewsindia PTC News , Punjabi News,Punjab Latest News,Latest News from Punjab,Punjab News Headlines,Top News from Punjab
More from this channel
-
0:18
Sadi kheti , agriculture show on PTC News
-
1:30
Rakkhan Puniya - SAD
-
0:41
MANDI revised
-
9:21
PS EP 174 2
-
10:31
straight talk harsimrat kaur badal sig_01.mpg
-
11:53
straight talk harsimrat kaur badal sig 02
-
11:07
straight talk harsimrat kaur badal sig 03
-
8:50
straight talk harsimrat kaur badal sig 04