Daleel with SP Singh on Capital Punishment & Yakub Memon | Aug 05, 2015

1,751 views · Published 6 August 2015 · 45:58 · Indexed 8 November 2026

Channel: PTC NEWS · 2015 · News & Politics

Watch on YouTube

Watch Daleel with SP Singh on Capital Punishment & Yakub Memon

Our panelists will include --
1. Mr Satpal Jain, Additional Solicitor General of India 
2. Mr Rajwinder Bains, well known human rights activist
3. Prof Rajiv Lochan, Head, History Department and columnist
4. Arjun Sheoran, from People's Union of Civil Liberties
Why was Kasab's death penalty not waived off? And they also want to save Nirbhaya's killers from gallows! They are well meaning, widely respected human rights activists. Do they have a point? This episode of DALEEL WITH SP SINGH has activists questioning the Deep State and the noose. Even as BJP leader & Additional Solicitor General of India, Satpal Jain, digs in his heels and asks if these compassion-imbued Samaritans believe in any democratic institution -- including the apex court & the President of India, the academic on the panel hits back: "Really? But why is this President sending everyone to the gallows?" 
Provocative, and with no punches pulled. 
Panelists point out about Capital Punishment being banished by so many countries, underline how human life is precious and that later facts sometimes have proved in the past that the accused/convicts were innocent. Thus, irreparable injustice happens. Also, death is not a deterrent and retribution is a bad aim
Does “rarest of rare” doctrine require tightening of rules, more safeguards, codified definitions?
If death is no deterrence, is jail term a better deterrent? 
Punishment is how we educate ourselves on what is acceptable or unacceptable to a society. 
Besides, all sentences are retribution, so that people don’t take law into their own hands and seek retribution directly. Retribution is a human emotion that needs to be acknowledged – just as love, anger and hate are 
Some nagging questions remain -- Isn't clemency the prerogative of the state? Can compassion be the unassailable right of the accused?
This episode of DALEEL with SP SINGH was telecast on PTC News on August 5, 2015. Feedback, suggestions welcome at [email protected]. Also, please help spread the word about DALEEL, an effort at cerebral television in times of dumbing down of the news media.
Thank you for watching. DALEEL WITH SP SINGH is telecast every Wednesday at 9 pm on PTC News.

More from this channel