Daleel with SP Singh - Shaheed Bhagat Singh, Nationalism & Bharat Mata

712 views · Published 25 March 2016 · 45:10 · Indexed 10 November 2026

Channel: PTC NEWS · 2016 · News & Politics

Watch on YouTube

On the panel -
Dr Akshay Kumar
Academician and Public Intellectual
Gobind Thukral
Sr Journalist and scholar
Pankaj Jain
Advocate and Head, Ekatam Manav Pratishthan
Prof Ishwar Dayal Gaur
Deptt of History & Author, Martyr as Bridegroom -  A Folk Representation of Bhagat Singh
At a time when freedom of speech and nationalism are being bandied about like two mutually exclusive concepts, and challenging debates are hotting up in JNU, Hyderabad Central University, Aligarh Muslim University, Jadavpur University, FTII and campuses across the country, it is interesting to attempt to understand the concept of nationalism at a time when competing interests are contesting the legacy of Shaheed Bhagat Singh, Rajguru, Sukhdev and many other martyrs.
Lest it is decided by a cow, or some other meat stored in a fridge in Dadri, it is time that we tried to understand Nationalism in more liberal, broader contexts.
Panelists wonder why after decades of Independence are we a nation so insecure that we need to go back and worry about vast sections of Indians not possibly being nationalists.
Of course, all governments by default lack confidence and are uncomfortable with an independent citizenry. They need something to be against. Cong has this monster in "Communalism" and BJP has found this new love for "Nationalism" in which perhaps everyone not in BJP is anti-national. Or at least anyone not heard loudly shouting Jai of a Mother called Bharat.
Jai Hind, it seems, will fall short. Silence will certainly be a sign of being a traitor.
But is nationalism limited to flying flags on official buildings and singing the glories of the nation symbolised as a mother? 
At the time of freedom struggle, some wanted an Islamic state and got Pakistan. Others did not opt for a Hindu Rashtra. They made for themselves a liberal, secular, democratic state. Even socialist. 
But how hardcore a nationalist I must be not to be beaten up by the brigade that prefers a bovine variety of nationalism?
French intellectual and writer, Albert Camus, once wrote, "I love my country too much to be a nationalist". Gau-raksha brigade would probably not be very kind to him, certainly not in Dadri.
Those who forged India's constitution were ardent liberal democrats. This debate asks how they would have seen the tortured debate about nationalism and free expression in India taking place today.
Also, the organised political Left which wants to ride piggyback on 24x7 and social media wonders in the wake of Kanhaiya Kumar maintained a curious and deafening silence when unpopular views and ideas were under attack earlier. Did you try free speech in Calcutta during left rule?
Why should we be asked to choose between liberalism and nationalism conveniently represented by Left and Sangh Parivar? 
Can we insist on both?
This episode of DALEEL with SP SINGH was telecast on PTC News on March 23, 2016. Feedback, suggestions welcome at [email protected]. Also, please help spread the word about DALEEL, an effort at cerebral television in times of dumbing down of the news media.
Thank you for watching. DALEEL WITH SP SINGH is invariably telecast every Wednesday at 9 pm on PTC News. Repeat telecast is normally on Thursday, at 2 pm. But please always check the latest schedule, and do not bet your money on it.

More from this channel