Matcha - what evidence is there to back up the health claims?
552 views · Published 18 March 2018 · 5:16 · Indexed 8 November 2026
Channel: Alan Heath · 2018 · Howto & Style
I was walking around Tesco and I came across some Matcha tea. I have heard a lot about Matcha and being into health food decided to give it a try. After all if Dr. Michael Greiger from Nutrition Facts says that he never leaves his house without it then it must be good. The first thing I noticed was the price and it is not cheap – but the benefits may be great so that would take care of the price. So, as always, I turned to the US National Library of Medicine, National Institutes of Health website which has the largest collection of medical studies in the world and found a variety of studies there. Matcha is a powdered green tea produced by grinding with a stone mill. It has been consumed for at least 1,200 years when it was first mentioned getting a lot of praise in the process. It is a bit like ‘instant tea’ – I am using that expression in the very loosest sense - as when put in a cup with water at around 80C and stir it vigorously it will dissipate – unless you put too much in, in which case it will form a sludge at the bottom of the cup which you can use for your next shot. Consuming all your tea leaves makes sense, you will get the full dose of nutrients, after all after preparing Brussels Sprouts you don’t throw the vegetables out and drink the cooking water. When I have green tea, I usually eat the leaves too but I am a bit odd and probably the only person in the world that does this. Looking at nutritional information, macha will give you a tiny bit of vitamin A, iron and protein but you will have to be drinking the stuff non stop and by the barrelful to see any benefit on that front. However macha contains more chlorophyll than any other tea (I think) and that is full of anti-oxidants. The results of a September 2003 experiment suggested that there were between three and 137 times more of the anti oxidant ESCG in matcha than in other green tea. The reputation of matcha comes from purported positive effects on mood and research has shown that three constituents present in matcha tea, l-theanine, the anti oxidant EGCG and caffeine, affect mood and cognitive performance. Sounds good so far. However a September 2017 study found it may only induce slight effects on speed of attention. Another 2017 test showed that it was caffeine that was mainly responsible for improvements in cognitive tasks and self-reported alertness, arousal, and vigor. One needs to take at least 200mg of l-theanine to see improved self-reported relaxation, tension, and calmness. L-theanine and caffeine combined were found to particularly improve performance in attention-switching tasks and alertness, but to a lesser extent than caffeine alone. Therefore those taking it as a replacement for an expresso might be disappointed. Claims have been made about its role in fighting cancer but more work here needs to be done. There are some preliminary suggestions that it may be helpful in the early stages of certain types of cancer but at present we know too little. Other studies have shown that it reduces dental plaque in dogs and helps with type two diabetes in rats as well as glucose levels in mice. On the other hand, I found nothing negative about it as far as people were concerned but that is not the case for fruit flies. So, assuming you are not a fruit fly and you like the taste drink it, but don’t expect it to make you the next Einstein! If anyone can point to serious research showing medical breakthroughs then I will gladly update this! Photo by Artur Rutkowski