Daleel with SP Singh, on freebies, populist policies, atta-dal scheme, Amma of Tamil Nadu

433 views · Published 12 May 2016 · 44:19 · Indexed 8 November 2026

Channel: PTC NEWS · 2016 · News & Politics

Watch on YouTube

On the panel:

1. Hamir Singh, senior journalist, activist 
2. Kuldip Kaul, industrialist and social thinker 
3. Arjun Sheoran, lawyer, activist; PUCL spokesperson 
4. Prof S K Chadha, Chairperson, UBS (University Business School), Chandigarh

At a time when Tamil Nadu is going to elections, much of media coverage and political rhetoric is centred around what neo-liberals love to call "freebies" being doled out to the janta of this southern state.

This episode of Daleel focusses on the distinction between freebies and incentives, engages with the debate on whether it is prudent to give out free LPG stoves, television sets, laptops to students, mixers and grinders, cows and goats to rural poor, heavily subsidised food canteens in major urban centres. 

Panelists talk about growing vulnerability of agrarian livelihoods, and the impact of these direct benefit measures in reduction of poverty. 
While all political parties indulge in such "competitive welfarism," the market-centric argument calls it fiscal profligacy and handouts that make people lazy and are mere attempts to buy off voters. 

More importantly, the debate underlines the fact that such arguments tend to ignore global trends in welfare interventions in post-colonial societies in the last two decades. 

In case you are interested in the reference to James Ferguson, the renowned anthropologist, in the debate. In his 2015-book Give a Man a Fish: Reflections on the New Politics of Distribution, he points out that there has been an increase in non-contributory transfers to citizens in many third world countries because the modern capitalist sector simply cannot absorb the dispossessed population. He argues that the classical model of demanding social welfare primarily as workers was not working. Production of wealth requires less labour than before, rendering large segments of the population “surplus”. 

“Teach a man to fish and you feed him for a lifetime.” But now, fewer and fewer fishers required to net more and more fish. So, it is better to make a claim on the share of fish caught, irrespective of whether one has worked to catch them or not. 

Social wealth owes itself to collective labour and ownership, and that ought to be the basis of claim-making.

Is welfare provisioning irreversible, given the unpopularity that withdrawal entails? 

This episode of DALEEL with SP SINGH, was telecast on PTC News on May 11, 2016. Feedback, suggestions welcome at  [email protected]. Also, please help spread the word about DALEEL, an effort at cerebral television in times of dumbing down of the news media.

Thank you for watching. DALEEL WITH SP SINGH is now telecast every Wednesday at 7 pm on PTC News. Repeat telecast is normally on Thursday, at 2 pm. But TV channels can change schedules without notice. So, please always check the latest schedule, and do not bet your money on it.

More from this channel