3 Banjo Comparison: Yates, Hatfield, Gibson conversion

4,227 views · Published 16 March 2015 · 2:09 · Indexed 25 October 2026

Channel: Bryan Haywood · 2015 · Music

Watch on YouTube

I currently own a Hatfield Buckcreek (mahogany), a Yates rs-maple, and a 1930 tb-2 conversion (mahogany). Each feel and sound different when you play them in person than what I hear on the video.  I know that these videos and sound clips are not always representative of being there live, but I like doing these types of raw recordings.  Here's a little more about each banjo:

The Yates is a 2011 Ron Stewart Maple model, and it is the same age as the Hatfield. Its sound is much deeper with the notes sounding like they come from the back of the resonator. It it also has the best 4th string of the two and I feel that it has more of the prewar sound with the pleasing overtones it gives off.  I tend to think that the Yates sounds better than the Hatfield in person.

I bought the Hatfield new and it really opened up after playing it for a couple of years. It has a very clear sound which feels like the notes come directly off of the banjo head. I feel like the clarity would make it a good banjo to use for melodic, single-string, or Scruggs style playing. The Hatfield also seems to record very well. Most folks (myself included) think that it sounds better than the Yates on recordings.

The prewar is in a different class with regard to the tone in my opinion. Great balance with the fourth string and ringing highs. It also has sentimental value to me and I would be biased when trying to compare it to the other banjos.  I will say that is my favorite banjo for a number of reasons.

In short, if you are looking for balanced tone with great clarity that can be used for many different playing styles, then a Hatfield is for you. If you want a banjo that sounds more like a prewar with extra depth due to pleasing overtones, go with a Yates. Hope this helps! Feel free to post your observations or questions below.

More from this channel