Dreamcast + Framemeister (+ Toro): Comparison with Different Setups (720p60)

2,395 views · Published 11 April 2016 · 7:28 · Indexed 16 November 2026

Channel: Fabio Santana · 2016 · Gaming

Watch on YouTube

A video comparing the image quality of Dreamcast using Ikaruga with four different setups, all indicated in this video with color-coded text - for best results, watch in full screen at 720p60 resolution.
For consistency, all setups output to a 720p resolution with no scanlines, and all were captured with an Elgato HD60. Check below for a more detailed look at each setup.

1) Green text (best): Toro advanced video box set to VGA mode (31khz) + SCART RGB cable to output a 480p image to the XRGB-mini Framemeister upscaler, which then scales the signal to 720p resolution.
• The SCART cable carries a very clean signal, delivering a crispier image
• The Toro video box is set to VGA mode, outputting a 480p image
• 480p is a progressive signal, which means it produces a complete image at each pass (60 times per second)
• Progressive signal results in more image detail: with an interlaced signal, the upscaler has to fill the empty lines by cloning existing lines (a process known as “line doubling”), whereas a progressive signal has real content in every line originally
• The XRGB-mini Framemeister is the pinnacle of upscalers for video games, producing precise colors with sharp pixels even in rapid movement, while at the same time keeping the original 4:3 aspect ratio for classic consoles
Framemeister Settings:
Image_Mode: Picture
Aspect_Ratio: 4:3
Color_Set: Brightness: 30, Gamma: 15, Black: 0, Sharpness: 1
Visual_Set: H_Scaler: 7, V_Scaler: 5
Special / A/D_Set / A/D_Level: 131

2) Yellow text (great): Toro advanced video box set to RGB mode (15khz) + SCART RGB cable to output a 480i image to the XRGB-mini Framemeister upscaler, which then scales the signal to 720p resolution.
• The same combo of Toro + SCART + Framemeister for a superb image quality
• The difference here is that Toro is set to RGB mode, outputting a 480i image instead
• 480i is an interlaced signal, which means it has to complete two passes to form a complete image, one to draw odd lines, and another to draw even lines (at 60 passes per second, a “complete” image is formed 30 times per second)
• To output at 720p (or 1080p, or any progressive resolution in fact), the upscaler needs to de-interlace, which means filling the empty lines by cloning the existing ones (or by averaging pixels between two existing lines)
• The XRGB-mini Framemeister also handles interlaced contents really well, but the resulting image with a 480i signal is less crispy and detailed than with a 480p source
Framemeister Settings:
Image_Mode: Natural
Aspect_Ratio: 4:3
Color_Set: Brightness: 30, Gamma: 15, Black: 0, Sharpness: 1
Visual_Set: Auto_Scaler: Video
Special / A/D_Set / A/D_Level: 131

3) Orange text (so-so): Composite cable to output a 480i image to the XRGB-mini Framemeister upscaler, which then scales the signal to 720p resolution.
• Instead of a SCART cable, this setup uses a much simpler composite cable to hook the Dreamcast directly to the XRGB-mini Framemeister
• Composite is that one that sends video signal through one single cable with a yellow end. Carrying color and sync information through a single cable, composite produces an image with a certain level of noise, chromatic aberration and a general sense of blurriness when compared to SCART RGB
• Nonetheless, the Framemeister does a great job of enhancing image quality here – if you don’t have a dedicated upscaler and hook your video game via composite cable directly to a modern flat TV, though,  expect an horrible image quality
Framemeister Settings:
Image_Mode: Natural
Aspect_Ratio: 4:3
Color_Set: Brightness: 30, Gamma: 15, Black: 0, Hue: 45, Saturation: 32, Sharpness: 1
Visual_Set: Auto_Scaler: Video
Special / A/D_Set / A/D_Level: 131

4) Red text (poor): Composite cable to output a 480i image to the Pioneer VSX-1123-K receiver, which then scales the signal to 720p resolution.
• Again using a composite cable, but this time replacing the Framemeister for a Pioneer VSX-1123-K receiver as the upscaler. The intention here was to compare with a non-specialized upscaler – although this receiver is not bad at upscaling either
• The Pioneer VSX-1123-K uses a Marvell QDEO video processor to upscale contents, which is meant to upscale video contents primarily, especially movie DVDs (for comparison’s sake, the Framemeister uses a more advanced Marvell QDEO Kyoto G2 processor)
• For a video game source via composite cable in 480i, the upscaling engine of this receiver is not ideal, but it still manages to clean up some noise associated to this kind of connection
• Still, the content is stretched to a 16:9 aspect ratio and the receiver lacks the range of image adjustment options that the Framemeister has, resulting in a more bland image overall
• Again, if you hook a classic video game directly to your modern flat TV and let it handles the upscaling, expect much worse results (I certainly did get an awful image quality out of my Samsung LED TV)

More from this channel