DALEEL with SP Singh # 21 | Yogendra Yadav and Devinder Sharma on Search for Alternative Politics

1,991 views · Published 9 April 2015 · 47:35 · Indexed 1 November 2026

Channel: PTC NEWS · 2015 · News & Politics

Watch on YouTube

Watch DALEEL with SP Singh as Yogendra Yadav, well known political scientist and psephologist turned politician, responds to his ideas of why his own search and creation, in the form of Aam Aadmi Party, failed to emerge, in his own words and perception, as a viable, sustainable political alternative, and what factors impact any honest search for his favourite Vaikalpic Rajneeti rather than Rajneetak Vaikalap.

Prof Yogendra Yadav, now living on the bare margins of AAP and better known as someone seen as a challenger to the crown and overthrown in a palace coup by more shrewd Arvind Kejriwal, did impress with his Punjabi, but did he with his arguments, too?

As Shalini Malviya, a vocal AAP volunteer from Haryana and Rajiv Godara, more a close associate of Yadav than a member of the AAP National Executive, nearly reflect the professor politician's line, Devinder Sharma stands his ground and is deeply suspicious of whether this is a valid way of looking for an alternative at all.

The well known food and agriculture policy analyst is scathing in his comments: "As long as you do not change the national discourse, all political parties have similar approaches and merely different rhetoric....Farmers are basically seen as either a vote bank or a land bank....Every time an issue involving contestation arises, political parties of all colours start quoting one or the other majboori." 

Anchor SP Singh questions Yogendra Yadav's claims of not being pigeon holed in ideological boxes of Left and Right, and asks if all that such a political alternative involves is delivery of cheap power, water, services, and if all concerns are about the middle class or lower middle class urban residents?

Here are some issues that DALEEL raises -- Is the route Yadav has taken is also a clever way of bypassing a tryst with the State? One would wait to see if Yadav underlines that the State, as it stands today, is itself a hurdle in the path of democratisation of society. "Was AAP custom designed to bypass this reality?"

Yadav is also asked why under his co-watch did AAP make corruption an ideology? And why was there such ‘economism’ in politics that focuses on the immediate: From maximum programme for socialism to minimum programme like Jan Lokpal Bill? Is the politics of AAP, the so-called post-ideological politics, limited in its vision? Such reformist vision willy-nilly ends up aligning with the status quo.


TAKE THIS EXAMPLE -- Low power tariff is a minimum demand. As a logical extension of this demand, AAP demands audit of accounts of pvt power co mpanies. They are alleged to have cut shady deals with the govt to jack up tariffs.
Anchor SP Singh: "This is where AAP’s logical progression seems to have got stalled. It does not ask: 
why such deals are common between big companies and governments? Why is the aam admi too poor to pay power bills? Is there a connection between the wealth of rich men who make those deals with the poverty of the aam admi? 
BECAUSE if they ask this, then it will lead to question about what keeps aam aadmi poor? It will raise quesions about a country of impressive number of Forbes-defined billionaires and Amit Sen Gupta committee-defined triply filtered 77% poor. That's not what Yadav-Kejriwal were saying till just a few months back. Yes, they indeed wanted Delhities to have cheap power.

So the allegation is more sinister: Perhaps those in search of Alternative Politics did not want to diagnose at all?

Can parties like AAP, even a better AAP, be a force to transform the system? Myopic democracy is no democracy at all. 

Just before the end of the programme comes a more sinister question -- Is Yogendra Yadav a master of  intelligent silences? 

Watch this DALEEL episode to know Yadav's answers.

More from this channel