Ninja Game of Thrones

1,536 views · Published 8 December 2015 · 14:21 · Indexed 29 October 2026

Channel: Antony Cummins · 2015 · Education

Watch on YouTube

Get the ninja manuals here
http://www.antonycummins.com/publications.html

Steven's message
I have been asked this a dozen times, so I will just post my reply to everyone:
"Why did you leave ninjutsu research?"
Answer : Because I realized that almost everyone of my ex-contemporaries are using ninjutsu research as a way to get into a giant dick measuring contest and the actual topic of ninjutsu-in-context was ignored. That is, there doesn't seem to be any attempt to comprehend or understand the relationship of ninjutsu to the families who practiced it. Ninjutsu, and samurai history in general, keeps being portrayed as an amorphous disconnected "lore in the sky". The reality is that it is a very specific set of culture which existed solely within the possession of specific individuals and families. It cannot be accessed via any route other than through those individuals and families (their history, their culture, their memories, etc.) In short, what I failed to see was people trying to authentically portray "ninjutsu-in-context". There was always, and continues to be, an effort to try and produce a ninjutsu which is somehow disconnected from its context. Beyond that, there continued to be an effort, seemingly on all fronts (to various degrees), to try and bullshit ownership of ninjutsu--- literally, steal it from its proper owners and somehow lay claim to it (via various methods and permutations). I found such efforts to be irresponsible. This same pattern tends to be the norm for bushi research in general, albeit, not as bad as ninjutsu-specific research. Something about ninjutsu-specific research really seems to summon forth some rather shameful behaviors. I will give an example : Mie University's research team. They claim to be the only people qualified to do ninjutsu research, yet they keep producing the same irrational (meaning "out of context") material. Even they fail to tie ninjutsu to its actual context. Instead, their material continues to feed the flames of their ego and their tourism. I would be astounded if that team ever produced material which actually dived head first into the nuts-and-bolts of the actual culture and politics of the specific families which practiced ninjutsu. I would love, for example, to see a 200 page book analyzing the various nuts-and-bolts of Oda Nobunaga's shinobi-specialized retainers, going into their history, their motivations, their politics, their lineage charts, their religious beliefs, and how that all squared with their service to the House of Oda, etc... But, I really do not believe we will ever see this. Why? Simply because that team isn't out to produce responsible and accurate material. It is out to secure tourism in Mie. The skewed research is just to a marketing strategy. It is a glorified commercial. This Mie team will, predictably, stay far away from ever showing Oda Nobunaga's extensive use of shinobi solely for the fact that they constantly grind their agenda of making Iga out to be the Ninja-Capital, thus, securing lots of future tourism. 

Message was too long. Half deleted.

More from this channel