Colin Renfrew - Studying Obsidian to build up a picture of trading networks (24/79)
361 views · Published 19 September 2017 · 9:34 · Indexed 20 October 2026
Channel: Web of Stories - Life Stories of Remarkable People · 2017 · Science & Technology
To listen to more of Colin Renfrew’s stories, go to the playlist: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g3SzEpbhIMI&list=PLVV0r6CmEsFxuotjBVsYwbMI_I94P6Sq7 Baron Renfrew of Kaimsthorn (1937-2024) was a British archaeologist known for his work on the dispersal of the Proto-Indo-Europeans and the prehistory of PIE languages. He was Disney Professor of Archaeology at Cambridge as well as Master of Jesus College and Director of the McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research. [Listener: Paul Bahn] TRANSCRIPT: The Obsidian was really a very interesting piece of work for me. Because I was doing my doctoral research in the Cyclades, I wanted to understand what was going on in the Cyclades and therefore the obsidian question became a very important one, perhaps more important than it would otherwise have done, and so there were these obsidian sources, two main obsidian sources on Melos, which I'd been able to visit and then it was suggested that the obsidian used in Malta might have come from Melos whereas it was known that there was a source nearer to Malta at Lipari just off the North coast of Sicily, and so that was a problem that it looked as if it would be very interesting to solve and also there's a lot of obsidian being found in Turkey and in the Near East and the question was where as all this obsidian coming from and how could you work that out? And so I had the good fortune to discuss this in St John's College with an old friend of mine, Joe Cann, who had been in the same class as I was. We were both in the same class in St Alban's School and he'd gone and he hadn't done national service. He'd got deferment and then in the end he hadn't done national service and he'd become a geologist and petrologist so he agreed to look at the question, and my job was to get good samples of obsidian from wherever I could so I got plenty from - from Melos and then I wrote to David Trump who was working in Malta and he gave me samples of what was being found in Malta. Then with Joe we went through the collections of the department of mineralogy and petrology in Cambridge, and there they had abundant obsidian samples from the sources, like Lipari and so on, and so we looked at it first of all from the standpoint of refractive index which obviously would be an optical technique and we couldn't really see much - much difference there. We looked at it systematically and there wasn't much to be done. On the terms of appearance there wasn't much systematic difference so Joe suggested that we should do trace element analysis by means of optical emission spectroscopy which was a fairly new technique then, a standard technique in mineralogy and petrology, and it involved getting quite small samples and grinding them up in a pestle and mortar and then he had access to a machine which was run by a technician when these were burnt in the machine, and then the spectrum produced was recorded on a photographic plate and then you could read the intensity of the spectral lines, the spectral lines being caused by the presence of trace elements of these various - so it was possible to get estimates, semi-quantitative estimates, for the quantities in parts per million of these various trace elements that were present in the obsidian. And so we looked systematically at the obsidian samples from Melos and those from Lipari and the other known sources that we could get our hands on, and there did, in the end, seem to be some systematic differences. If you plotted them on a graph of barium against zirconium in parts per million, you could separate the Melian sources from the Lipari sources and separate those from the Sardinian sources and those from the sources in - in Hungary, although from the - from the Pontine Islands, which are off the coast of Italy, they didn't differ very much from the Lipari ones until we looked, until Joe looked, at a new trace element we hadn't looked at before, which was caesium and he said - I was in - in Athens by then so he sent to me a message saying that caesium allowed one to distinguish between the two so I sent him a telegram saying, ‘Congratulations, caesium!’ and this really helped to sort of crack the problem and so it became possible having learned how to discriminate the materials from the sources, to characterise the verb we introduced, to characterise the materials from the sources, it became possible to look at the samples from Malta, from other archaeological sites, and do the trace elements analysis on them and see which they matched up with. And the Maltese specimens matched up with mainly with Lipari and the suggestion that there'd been contacts between the Cyclades and Malta as documented by the Melian obsidian, proved to be completely unwarranted. Read the full transcript on [https://www.webofstories.com/play/colin.renfrew/24].
More from this channel
-
0:44
David Weatherall - Entering medical school
-
1:33
Katharine Whitehorn - Embodying the 'Sluts' article
-
6:55
KG Subramanyan - Mohandas Gandhi's views on art
-
2:22
Baruch Blumberg - The link between some cancers and viruses
-
5:03
Carl Djerassi - How Picasso sculpture unveiled problems in my marriage
-
6:39
Renato Dulbecco - Three Nobels, just one class
-
2:26
Marek Edelman - Different criteria for measuring the value of human life
-
2:45
Jules Engel - So who is responsible for a great animation?