Am I Overthinking This? - Question and Answer - Architect Registration Exam | ARE Live

648 views · Published 18 May 2016 · 7:43 · Indexed 28 October 2026

Channel: Black Spectacles · 2016 · Education

Watch on YouTube

ARE Prep powered by Black Spectacles-
blackspectacles.com/courses
Mike's Recommended Resources to pass the ARE:
http://blackspectacles.com/blog/books-need-to-pass-are-exam-resources 

All right. Michael asks, "What is your advice and/or do you have a state of mind rules of thumb..." I like that, Michael, "...for how we should be thinking when taking the PPP and CDS exam? 

I'm having difficulty answering multiple choice situational questions because I'm projecting what I would do or have already done in real practice versus what the AIA wants me to do to pass the exam. Distinguishing the two is my biggest challenge. I know the content, but I can't really interpret the questions and answers correctly. I'm always able to narrow down to a couple choices, but they seem equally acceptable in terms of the question. So it always brings me to a kind of 'Well, it depends.' Is there a way to clarify the question? If I had a way to hit a 'clarify the question' button on the exam, I would hit it." I love that idea. You should suggest that to NCARB. "Am I overthinking this?" 

So my first response is, if you say to yourself, "I wonder if I'm overthinking this?" I can almost guarantee you, you're overthinking it. The short answer to your question is, we all work in a real world, but the exam can't really be about the real world because the real world is so real and so different in so many different places, and it's not really the point. The point of the exam is to say, "This is how contractually things make sense." 

I'll give you a quick example. In the contracts, it's very clear that the architect's role, if you look at the B101 compared to the A101, which is the contractor's contract, the architect's role is for the design intent. The contractor's role, among a few others, is for the means and methods. It's for actually making that design manifest. So there's all sorts of things in that means. One of them is if there's a safety issue on the site, it is not the architect's role to comment about it or to do anything about it. 

The site means and methods, that includes how they do it, whether it's safe or not, all of that stuff falls under the contractor's duties. So, if you walk onto a job site and there's a big ditch on one side and there's no railing to stop, a temporary railing to stop people from falling into the ditch while they're moving lumber around or something, and you stand there and you say, "Wow, this is really dangerous. You should put a railing here." 

Technically, you just usurped the liability for all the safety issues on the site because you became an expert and said, "I am now taking over liability of the safety issues on the site by telling you, 'Put a railing here,'" which in that one example, it's probably not a big deal. But then three months later, when something else happens, and the contractor tells their insurance company, "Well, that guy did say something about the railing a while back," suddenly that insurance company says, "Oh, great. That means we don't have to pay this. That means their insurance company has to pay this," and it could become a really big problem. 

So there are very clear rules. If you see a question that says, "You see a safety problem on the site. A, should I call owner, or B, should I do...?" The answer is always going to be the least thing because it's not your role to do it. Okay, real world, really? I'm going to stand there and let somebody fall down into a shaft or into a big ditch and hurt themselves? No, of course, I'm going to mention something to somebody. But I'm going to know because I've read the contracts, I've been through this before, and I've talked to people about it that that's an issue, and so I'm going to be very careful about how I talk about it. 

The real world situation, like, "I'm not going to let somebody get hurt," that doesn't make any sense, but it also doesn't make sense to just ignore the realities of the contracts. So that's a long way of getting to, yeah, there is the real world, that is not what the question is about. The question is about, "How does NCARB and the AIA and frankly the lawyers for the AIA think you should answer the question?" So I always suggest people, when they read the questions, you should never think, just as a mindset issue, you should never think, "I wonder what the right answer is."

More from this channel