'Why Presidentialism is Bad for Democracy' by Dana Nelson
1,656 views · Published 27 March 2017 · 1:01:32 · Indexed 12 November 2026
Channel: Vanderbilt University · 2017 · Education
Watch video of the talk 'Why Presidentialism is Bad for Democracy' by Dana Nelson, Gertrude Conaway, Professor of English. October 5, 2005 In the US, the President stands for democracy as the nation's (and the world's) "most powerful man." Every four years, we ferociously debate which candidate will be good for us, which one will be a disaster for the nation. Once he's installed, we credit him with what we like about our current state, and we blame him for what we find wrong. People feel strongly about their presidents: we love them, and we hate them, and these days, there's little in between. This talk redirects our attention toward the presidency. It argues that it's not the President who causes problems for the nation: it's presidentialism. Presidentialism has been bad for democracy despite the particular virtues and leadership skills of many presidents. Presidentialism is bad because it trains us to want to President to take care of democracy for us instead of remembering that democracy, properly defined, is our job. It's bad because it trains us to see democracy as being represented by a single body, a strong leader representing a strong consensus, instead of remembering that disagreement is a good word for democracy. It leads us to overemphasize democracy as unity, instead of helping us remember that a decently working disunity can make us even stronger as a nation. This talk proposes that we put less energy into being mad at the president and more energy into finding ways to revitalize democratic practice--no matter who is president. Follow Vanderbilt on Twitter: https://twitter.com/vanderbiltu, on Instagram: http://instagram.com/vanderbiltu and on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/vanderbilt. See all Vanderbilt social media at http://social.vanderbilt.edu.