DALEEL with SP SINGH - Should India talk to Pakistan after terror attacks in Kashmir?

464 views · Published 19 February 2018 · 48:29 · Indexed 31 October 2026

Channel: PTC NEWS · 2018 · News & Politics

Watch on YouTube

With Mehbooba Mufti advocating resumption of India, Pakistan talks as key to stopping terror attacks in her state, many are asking what happened to the policy of talks and terror not going together? Mufti said she knows many TV channels will call her 'anti-national' for floating the idea of talks. So, she knows wider public sentiment, or is it a creation of 'North Korean' channels? 

On the panel:

1. Gobind Thukral
Editor, South Asia Post; proactively worked with SAFMA

2. Vipin Pubby
Former Resident Editor, Indian Express; has reported from the troubled state of J&K as well as from the insurgency hit northeast 

3. Sarbjit Dhaliwal, 
Former Editor, Spokesman; worked with The Tribune for decades

4. Hamir Singh, 
Senior Journalist, expert on rural development part of Indo-Pak peace efforts


"Dialogue with Pakistan is necessary if we are to end bloodshed. I know I will be labelled anti-national by news anchors tonight but that doesn't matter. The people of Jammu and Kashmir are suffering. We have to talk because war is not an option."

This was Mehbooba Mufti hours after India lost six jawans in a deadly terror attack on Sunjuvan Army Camp in Jammu. Such attacks have increased in intensity recently, but the response is very different than it was after the attack on Uri. At that time, India had launched a surgical strike to punish Pakistan. Now, Defence Minister Nirmala Sitharaman merely sys Pakistan will have to pay for this adventurism. 

Do previous peace initiatives and corresponding trend of terror attacks and ceasefire violations support Mehbooba Mufti's prescription of talks for a solution?

While trend suggests terror incidents remained unaffected by peace initiatives and real factor is Pakistan establishment's policy towards terrorism/Kashmir, the panelists seem fairly convinced that talks are the only sensible way. And they make out a very strong case.

Are we looking helpless in our own backyard? Can India's new partnerships and alliances with Japan, Australia, Saudi Arabia, others in West Asia help in forcing Pakistan to change its behaviour? 

India has not been able to outgrow its region; it is tied down to its geography -- from Doklam to Kashmir, Maldives to Nepal, India is rudely reminded of its helplessness.

Is it affecting our diplomatic, moral and coercive authority? On the one hand, NSAs are apparently talking. On the other hand, a strong, muscular anti-Pakistan discourse is being encouraged. 
 
Is there a political strategy on Pakistan at all, 
or is it all bluster covering up a great floundering?

Panelists discuss China’s aggressive posture, hard power, diplomacy, alliances, political framing, an inconsistent domestic resolve and much else.

This episode of Daleel was first telecast on February 18, 2018, Sunday. Feedback, suggestions welcome at [email protected]. Also, please help spread the word about DALEEL, an effort at cerebral television in times of dumbing down of the news media.
 

Thank you for watching. DALEEL WITH SP SINGH is ordinarily telecast every Sunday at 8 pm on PTC News. The repeat telecast is at 2 pm the next day, Monday. Please check listings as TV channels often change schedules without notice. So, check out the time, and since it may still change, do not bet your money on it.

More from this channel