Uri Avnery - The rise and fall of Shmuel ‘Gorodish’ Gonen (187/315)
1,136 views · Published 26 July 2017 · 4:04 · Indexed 26 October 2026
Channel: Web of Stories - Life Stories of Remarkable People · 2017 · News & Politics
To listen to more of Uri Avnery’s stories, go to the playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLVV0r6CmEsFw4EQRLZvAoreWVLWLJDNaI Uri Avnery (1923-2018) was an Israeli writer, journalist and peace activist. He was editor-in-chief of the weekly news magazine "HaOlam HaZeh" and founded the Gush Shalom peace movement. [Listener: Anat Saragusti; date recorded: 2017] TRANSCRIPT: Then the war between the generals began. The war ended as a war of everyone against everyone else. There was the Agranat Commission which brought down Gorodish [Shmuel Gonen], who was guilty of everything. We need to remember that for a very short time Gorodish was head of the Southern Command; he didn't know the area, he was not familiar with the balance of power. He was not a great commander although he was probably a very good general. This is a problem that the IDF is not familiar with. In the German army, for example, a clear distinction is made between the two types of officers, to the extent that the red stripe down the length of the trousers comes in two different shades of red. There were command officers and there were staff officers, and this was so on the assumption that the two functions require different characteristics. There were generals who could command the troops and surge forward and conquer, and generals who would sit in the office, make plans and manage the war by moving troops around plus everything that this involved, organizing the home front. We, of course, are not familiar with this. In the army and also in civilian life there is the Peter principle. The Peter principle is named after an English professor from Singapore who invented it and wrote a book about it. He said: 'In a hierarchy every employee tends to rise to his level of incompetence'. Why? It is a completely natural process: a person succeeds, he is promoted. He succeeds, is promoted. Eventually he arrives at some level where he is incompetent, but he has arrived there naturally and that's how he ends his career − in a job for which he was not qualified. In the army this phenomenon is quite obvious. You can be an excellent corps commander, a great field commander and then you reach some stage which requires characteristics which you don't have. It happened to Gorodish. Gorodish was apparently a very good combat commander. In the Six Day War he really excelled; I think he was the first to arrive at the [Suez] Canal. Head of the Southern Command was already a strategic role and that was already beyond his capabilities. He replaced Ariel Sharon who had been Head of the Southern Command and shortly before the war, a few weeks or months, Gorodish replaced Arik. Gorodish had a great reputation. He was the person who in the previous war had reached the Canal! And so he went one step higher. It totally didn't suit him to be the commander of the front line in this war. He was full of arguments. The Commission dismissed him in disgrace from his position and from the army. They really put all the blame on him.
More from this channel
-
0:44
David Weatherall - Entering medical school
-
1:33
Katharine Whitehorn - Embodying the 'Sluts' article
-
6:55
KG Subramanyan - Mohandas Gandhi's views on art
-
2:22
Baruch Blumberg - The link between some cancers and viruses
-
5:03
Carl Djerassi - How Picasso sculpture unveiled problems in my marriage
-
6:39
Renato Dulbecco - Three Nobels, just one class
-
2:26
Marek Edelman - Different criteria for measuring the value of human life
-
2:45
Jules Engel - So who is responsible for a great animation?