Commentary - The Nintendo Creators Program puts fair use and journalism at risk

2,671 views · Published 30 January 2015 · 4:56 · Indexed 12 November 2026

Channel: Lon.TV · 2015 · Science & Technology

Watch on YouTube

Nintendo, which has always been heavy handed in how it treats the use of its content on YouTube, has launched a new program to share revenue with creators that use the company's games in a video. 

Nintendo claims independent content with their gameplay footage as theirs, and then denies the creator the right to earn revenue on that content. Ad revenue on those videos goes straight to Nintendo - not to the creator that made the video in the first place, including those who have a right to use that content!

On the surface the new Nintendo Creators Program sounds like a nice way to try and balance the issue for YouTubers. Nintendo says they'll share 60-70% of the revenue they're taking with the creator. But what it does instead is create a potentially dangerous precedent for journalism. 

Product reviews are fair use under US copyright law. If a reviewer is evaluating a copyrighted work they have the right to display portions of that work in the course of that evaluation. To have Nintendo stake copyright claims on that content is wrong in the first place, but now Nintendo is going a step further by deciding which content can earn revenue and which can't. So will they ever allow a critical review to earn revenue after the company claimed that video as their own? Doubtful. 

This sets a dangerous precedent. Nintendo shouldn't be allowed to do what they have been doing especially with product reviews. They should do what any good company would - respect the rights of creators, and keep their hands out of the pockets of their fans.

Subscribe to my email list to get a weekly digest of upcoming videos! - http://lon.tv/email

Visit the Lon.TV store to purchase some of my previously reviewed items! http://lon.tv/store

Want to help the channel? Start a Patreon subscription!
http://lon.tv/patreon

Follow me on Facebook!
http://facebook.com/lonreviewstech

Follow me on Twitter!
http://twitter.com/lonseidman

Follow me on Google+
http://lonseidman.com

More from this channel