Babysitter Speaks Out About Murder of Young Boys

1,079 views · Published 21 August 2015 · 2:28 · Indexed 28 October 2026

Channel: Dayton 24/7 Now · 2015 · News & Politics

Watch on YouTube

BELLEFONTAINE -- The Bellefontaine mother charged with killing her three sons is being held on a  million bond. Brittany Pilkington, 23, was silent as she made her first appearance in court Thursday in Logan County. "It's going to be rough," said Pilkington's father Ed Cummins about the court proceedings, "as you guys have seen it was rough on me today." Cummins was visibly shaken up during the arraignment, holding his head in his hands as he watched his daughter sit before a judge, but on Pilkington's face, there was no emotion. "She was always kind of quiet and weird around me but I just couldn't imagine anyone killing their kids," said a Bellefontaine teen who told ABC 22/FOX 45 she regularly babysat for the Pilkington kids. The babysitter attended the funeral for 4-year-old Gavin in April 2015. "She didn't seem emotional at all throughout the service. Me and my mom were both crying and I never saw a tear in her eye, she never seemed like it faced her whatsoever," the babysitter said. The child, who we spoke to with her mother's permission, did not want to be identified. "Hopefully, she can get the help she needs," Ed Cummins said. Brittany Pilkington's mother, Lori Cummins, said her daughter told her she did not commit the murders, that she felt coerced to confess. Logan County Prosecutor Bill Goslee said Pilkington confessed to the killings when she was interrogated after Noah's death. "[That] runs through my mind but I mean, if you didn't do it why admit to it," Cummins said. "It's just really made me realize that you can't trust anyone, and I guess everyone's different than what they come off," said the babysitter. Brittany Pilkington did not enter a plea on Thursday. The case will be heard by a grand jury on Tuesday. Jeff Skaggs, Brittany's uncle, said the family is pleading to know the whereabouts of Jo Pilkington, Brittany's husband, because they need to make funeral arrangements for Noah. Originally posted August 20, 2014.

More from this channel