David Weatherall - Looking into issues surrounding animal research (32/38)
54 views · Published 5 October 2017 · 7:46 · Indexed 8 November 2026
Channel: Web of Stories - Life Stories of Remarkable People · 2017 · Science & Technology
To listen to more of David Weatherall’s stories, go to the playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLVV0r6CmEsFxwQ7NSziz_XdC66gP3lyYj British scientist David Weatherall (1933-2018) was a world renowned expert on blood diseases, in particular thalassemias, and used his expertise to help in developing countries. He founded the WIMM at Oxford in 1989 and was knighted in 1987. [Listener: Marcus Pembrey] TRANSCRIPT: The other thing that I’ve been involved in more recently was even worse, and that was this question really of animal research, particularly primates, I mean, things have got so bad that the Academy of Medical Sciences and the Royal Society and the Welcome and the MRC jointly sponsored this working group, and I don’t know why I took it on. They asked me to do it, I think, because I’ve never worked with an animal. I mean, I think I had a brief flirtation with a couple of pregnant sheep just after I got to Oxford, but it didn’t come to much, and it’s nice in our field, because you can take a couple of ml of blood and do all you want from humans, and they can’t complain. So we had this rather very heterogeneous group of people, Nick Ross again, and the, John Harris, the bioethecist from Manchester, and then one or two people who knew something, particularly neuroscientists who had worked with animals, and the pharmaceutical industry and so on. And we just met for 15 months, it took, and we tried to adjudicate ourselves, we went to establishments where there was monkey research going on, and I, I don’t know, you get all this kind of advice when you go in an see these beasts, I mean, we were told on no account must you make eye contact with a monkey. But I mean, people have told me that about my cat, and we seem to make eye contact okay, so I went into this building, it was one of the Oxford buildings, and the first thing I saw was this little rhesus monkey peering at me, so, it seems rude not to look back, you know, and we peered at each other for a second, and then he immediately peed all over me, and I thought maybe they were right. But it was fascinating to, we went to Porton as well, they wouldn’t show us too much, obviously, but we had, and we went to Edinburgh, and at the Oxford place, interviewed lots of people from both sides really, extensive interviews with people like the RSPCA, have got some very serious interest in this. And also we had neuroscientists in- very long procedure, very difficult actually. And we got into an enormous kind of, ethical issues about the fundamental rights of animals and consciousness and all these awful problems which are totally insoluble, as far as I’m concerned. It’s such a long history of this, I mean, I hadn’t realised until I started reading about it, you know, that, I mean, there was a huge battle in Oxford when, well, Lewis Carroll, as we know him, has tried to, got a petition at Oxford, so that there would never be a physiology department. Even going back to Doctor Johnson, you know, the 18th, 17th century, a lot of this was going on, and Oxford’s always been in the centre of these battles, still is, but it honestly seemed to me, at the end of the day after all this, that, what the only useful thing we could really do that was semi-new, was to investigate the science. Has it been worth it? Is it really justified? Because the public debate has always suggested, from the rather limited, I know opinion polls are not very good, that they’re comfortable if it’s for medical research, but if it’s for kind of what they would call, curiosity-driven science, particularly in the neurosciences, they just do not like monkeys with their heads full of electrodes if it’s just for a bit of curiosity. And so we did two or three areas, we couldn’t do everything, but we did particularly communicable disease, the big three killers and vaccine development and so on, and the neurosciences. And then we also tried to look in great detail at alternatives, because there’s a big feeling now in animal rights that we don’t need these whole animals anymore, and the, because the pharmaceutical industry, they use the vast majority of primates, it’s a huge number compared with the ordinary scientists. Are there methods which will start to replace the requirement for primates? Well, you go through the whole gamut of molecular and cell biology and genes, you know, promoter modifiers that are promoter signals so that you can do kind of metabolic studies in cells or small animals at least– some of it very preliminary. And at the end of the day it seemed to us that there were certain areas in vaccine development particularly, and in the neurosciences, relating to some of the major killers, where for the foreseeable future, it might be quite difficult to proceed without a relatively small number of primates... read the full transcript at [https://www.webofstories.com/play/david.weatherall/32]
More from this channel
-
0:44
David Weatherall - Entering medical school
-
1:33
Katharine Whitehorn - Embodying the 'Sluts' article
-
6:55
KG Subramanyan - Mohandas Gandhi's views on art
-
2:22
Baruch Blumberg - The link between some cancers and viruses
-
5:03
Carl Djerassi - How Picasso sculpture unveiled problems in my marriage
-
6:39
Renato Dulbecco - Three Nobels, just one class
-
2:26
Marek Edelman - Different criteria for measuring the value of human life
-
2:45
Jules Engel - So who is responsible for a great animation?