Stanford Marshmallow Experiment Is Bullshit

766 views · Published 16 August 2018 · 2:42 · Indexed 18 October 2026

Channel: Jonathan Mann · 2018 · Music

Watch on YouTube

Put a marshmallow in front of a child
And say, “OK you will get two
Marshmallow’s in 15 minutes
If you don’t each the one in front of you”

Then follow that child for 20 years
And if they ate the one right away
You’ll say look at what a loser you are 
I guess they were just built that way

Like hey poor people are poor people
Because it’s just something they did
Such as never learning to wait for things
When they were a kid

It’s the Stanford marshmallow

Many years later
Psychologists took a look 
At this famous experiment
That’s number 1 in all text books

Turns out when you control for variables
Like home environment
You get a whole other result to
The marshmallow experiment

Turns out the decision not to wait 
Can be totally rational
And it says more about the conditions 
At home than anything innate at all

Pull yourself up by the bootstraps boy
Yeah that doesn’t work so great
Some people aren’t even on the field
Some start the game on third base 

The moral of this story
Is pretty simple to grok
Beware science that only confirms
The status quo it locks 

You can see what you want
You can make the data fit
The Stanford marshmallow thing
Is straight up bullshit 

Hi there! If you're new around these parts, welcome. I'm Jonathan Mann. I write a song every single day, and I've been doing that for the last 9+ years.

Through sick days, tired days, days with no inspiration, the death of my grandma, the breakup of a 5 year long relationship, the marriage to my wife and the birth of our son - I've never missed a day. This is my life's work.

You can see my most current song, as well as songs from year's past over at http://songaday.org

If you want to support me in my Song A Day quest, there are several ways!. I have many albums for sale on Bandcamp: http://jonathanmann.bandcamp.com

You can also support me in a more sustainable way by becoming a subscriber on Bandcamp or joining of 130 other folks and backing me on Patreon: http://patreon.com/jonathanmann

You can listen hear my albums on Spotify:
https://open.spotify.com/artist/2JJuzwVeuU7RhIhw7TGbNR

And listen to all of Song A Day on Spotify: 
https://open.spotify.com/artist/4O4Rkb6K3ppeXyVvD6zBJA

More from this channel