Mothballing Rail Line between Gisborne and Napier

918 views · Published 24 April 2014 · 2:01 · Indexed 27 October 2026

Channel: gisborneherald · 2014 · Entertainment

Watch on YouTube

THE Government's decision to mothball the rail line between Gisborne and Napier was the correct decision and is supported by an in-depth regional economic study, says Minister of Transport Gerry Brownlie. Steven Joyce, Minister of Regional Development, and Mr Brownlee spoke to Gisborne district councillors, business people and other "stakeholders" in the province.

http://www.gisborneherald.co.nz/
https://www.facebook.com/gisborneherald
https://www.youtube.com/gisborneherald

Mr Brownlee said it had been 14 months since the Government "mothballed" the rail line. It had not been an easy decision. There was not enough volume of freight to justify the line but mothballing it meant options were kept open for the future. The line had been transporting 50,000 tonnes of freight before its closure. It needed 400,000 tonnes to break even and 800,000 tonnes to be profitable. The Government had come to power following the global financial crisis and invested $80 billion into infrastructure, including $1b to "turn KiwiRail around". Mr Brownlee said the East Coast Regional Economic Potential Study showed the decision to mothball the line had been the correct decision. 

The minister was challenged on that point during questioning on the grounds that much more logging would be coming on stream. Mr Brownlee said the regional study argued otherwise and he suggested the questioner should read it "on that point". Mr Joyce said forestry companies operated on small margins. They had told him they would not change their mode of transport. Most people had "moved on" from rail. Rail was "a cul-de-sac". It was difficult enough to make the Auckland to Wellington trunk line profitable. Mr Joyce said Gisborne and similar regions had led the country out of the global financial crisis. Gisborne had a great future. New Zealand recorded 11.1 percent economic growth between 2010 and 2013. Gisborne's growth had increased 14 percent during the same period. From 2007 to 2013, the New Zealand economy had grown 24.5 percent. Gisborne had grown 26.7 percent. Mr Joyce admitted the figures surprised him. The economic news about Gisborne was not all bad. The figures showed there had been growth in Gisborne.But there were still "two big problems" in relatively low incomes and a high level of unemployment. The East Coast Regional Economic Potential Study, put together at a cost of $180,000 from central government and local government funding, was an economic report that presented at a new depth of analysis. The economic study would be a template for other regions, Mr Joyce said. But there was "no silver bullet" for any district and much hard work would be needed.

Both ministers said they realised roading was a key issue for Gisborne. Mr Joyce said "it was that kind of year", in an apparent reference to the election, where further announcements could be made concerning roads other than those covered under the National Roads of Significance (RoNS) funding policy that has so exasperated some Gisborne District councillors. New Zealand Transport Agency is working on all seven RoNs in Auckland, Waikato, Tauranga, Wellington and Christchurch. Mr Joyce later said he wanted to lift investment in resilient, regional highways before the RonS were completed. He identified 10 key factors to grow the region. 

Filmed and Edited by
Ben Cowper

SUBSCRIBE!
http://www.youtube.com/subscription_center?add_user=gisborneherald

More from this channel