Is Europe in Monsanto’s pocket over glyphosate? (Fact or Fake)
378 views · Published 14 November 2017 · 1:49 · Indexed 6 November 2026
Channel: Rapporteur News · 2017 · News & Politics
Well, this is at least what European media report on a regular basis, basing themselves on studies by NGOs on glyphosate, the pesticide manufactured by Monsanto, which was classified as probably carcinogenic by an agency of the WHO. However, the reality is a little bit more complex. In fact, the European Commission and the 28 EU member states have tended to throw the ball back at each other when it comes to deciding whether or not to ban glyphosate. Brussels for instance, has repeatedly stated that the decision is a “shared responsibility” with the 28. Well, this is not entirely true. Indeed, legal experts say that, in the absence of a clear majority from EU countries on what to do about glyphosate, the European Commission is fully entitled to decide on its own. But Brussels chooses not to do so for political reasons. By throwing back the responsibility on EU member states, it avoids opening a Pandora’s Box about the work done by EFSA and ECHA – the two agencies responsible for the scientific assessment of glyphosate, whose lack of independence from industry was highlighted by the Monsanto Papers. In fact, EFSA is not opposed to reform and is actually ready to accept a stronger mandate that would give it greater investigative powers and bolster its legitimacy. But there is little hope that Europe can agree to such a reform any time soon. Indeed, a single scientific study can cost several tens of millions of euros in some cases. And according to ECHA, there are currently hundreds of substances in Europe that are waiting to be tested and evaluated.
More from this channel
-
2:13
Brussels Minute: EU Wine Reforms disputed
-
2:15
Europe Today: Microsoft's Future at Stake in European Court
-
1:38
EU Week Ahead: Trains, Toys, Sugar, Death Penalty
-
1:26
Europe Today: Barroso in New York for UN climate conference
-
1:58
Strasbourg Minute: Renewable Energy, EU must act
-
3:57
The Exxon Files; FOE targets climate change approach
-
4:47
Animal health strategy proposed for Europe
-
5:50
Europe Today: ELDR Congress in Berlin