GMC - ROUND ONE RESULTS/ROUND TWO INFO!

1,196 views · Published 11 November 2015 · 1:28 · Indexed 14 November 2026

Channel: DannyPhantomSG1 · 2015 · Film & Animation

Watch on YouTube

FINALLY.  First of all, major apologies for taking so long to get through the judging.  Speaking for myself, though, I now have a 60-page word document full of nothing but critique from judging 60+ videos for the past month.  8’)  Hooray!

Now, before the rage/sadness mob comes running, please try to remember that this is a contest and we unfortunately have to narrow down the participants as time goes on.  We, the judges, are human, and we have different opinions.  You may notice some of you scored high with one judge and low with another - that's why there are three judges.  To get a wider array of viewpoints.  Nothing about judging is objective, so please please PLEASE do not take your scores or your status in the competition personally.  This is all for fun and for the sake of improvement in the eyes of three opinionated editors.  

Again, keep an eye on your message box for your notes from the competition.  We were very thorough and have a lot of constructive criticism to hand out – which, again, is full of biased opinions and stuff that you as an editor might not agree with.  And that’s fine!  If you think your editing is the bomb and we’re just wrong – keep believing that!  Editing is an art, and it’s very difficult to judge it objectively.  

For the judging, we each had four categories to judge on: Flow, Effects, Timing, and Lyrical Flow.  We scored those on a scale of 5 each, so you will receive each of our individual scores out of a total of 20. Then you will see your final score, which is all of ours added together, and is out of 60.  The top three videos all received 58/60, and we advanced the top 32 videos (effectively halving the contestant number) which all received 43/60 or higher.

FOR ROUND TWO!  

Your song is the one listed in the video, which I have pitch changed just in case.  I don’t know how this band does with youtube-y stuff, so I’m being extra cautious.  The first round was a light, airy, uplifting song – so for round two we want to see something different.  Something dark, heavy, and full of sounds to play with.

Your video should be about one minute long, and the deadline is DECEMBER 10TH.    

All of the top 3 editors will receive 5 bonus points going into the next round.  Congrats!  

And now, the moment you’ve been waiting for since we posted the contest, the prizes we never announced!

First Place:

Promotion
A collab with one of us (length: 2 minutes), a dedication from the other two (length: one minute)
And poooossibly a real life prize we could mail to you.  Still working out the kinks in this.

Second Place:

Promotion
Dedication in the form of a collab between the three judges (length: one and a half minutes)

Third Place:

Promotion

GOOD LUCK EVERYONE!  And again, your notes are coming and should be in your inbox within the next 24 hours.  If you have any questions or concerns, just leave me a comment!  I'm super busy at the moment, but I'll do my best to respond.

More from this channel