Colin Renfrew - The issue of unprovenanced antiquities (Part 2) (62/79)
227 views · Published 19 September 2017 · 9:09 · Indexed 24 October 2026
Channel: Web of Stories - Life Stories of Remarkable People · 2017 · Science & Technology
To listen to more of Colin Renfrew’s stories, go to the playlist: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g3SzEpbhIMI&list=PLVV0r6CmEsFxuotjBVsYwbMI_I94P6Sq7 Baron Renfrew of Kaimsthorn (1937-2024) was a British archaeologist known for his work on the dispersal of the Proto-Indo-Europeans and the prehistory of PIE languages. He was Disney Professor of Archaeology at Cambridge as well as Master of Jesus College and Director of the McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research. [Listener: Paul Bahn] TRANSCRIPT: So the illicit traffic in antiquities panel was an interesting experience. I think it really made the, the relevant government departure, Department of Culture, Media and Sport think much more carefully than it had done and good marks to Alan Howarth for sort of realising that something needed to be done, and the Dealing in Cultural Objects Offences Act, it's not retrospective unfortunately - it was, became law in 2003 so it doesn't apply to anything that was found before 2003 and for that reason it hasn't had very much impact yet, but I think it will do as time goes on and a lot of the antiquities that appear will have been found after 2003. And it makes it illegal knowingly to deal in antiquities found after that time and illegally excavated in or exported from their country of origin. And this is very new because it isn't just protecting British antiquities. Most antiquities laws of most nations are quite good at protecting their own antiquities but they're not very good at protecting antiquities from elsewhere, and so this I think is quite a significant development. But of course the collectors don't like it. I appeared in a television debate with George Ortiz when I was very critical of The Royal Academy for showing a collection that was full, a high proportion of unprovenanced antiquities and very critical of George Ortiz. He had initially been basking in the glory of having this magnificent, and there were wonderful pieces, and he's very erudite. He wrote the catalogue himself. He did the lighting himself and so on, but I ended up by saying that I hope George Ortiz was the last of the great collectors, and he liked the sound of the great collectors so he smiled at that, but it wasn't intended as a, as a compliment. But the campaign goes ahead in the United States and elsewhere because there the situation is much more scandalous. Whereas the British Museum, when it really thought about the problem ten years ago, decided to have a, an acquisitions code, an ethical acquisitions code, the Metropolitan Museum of Art has declined to do so and articles have been written, criticising their position. Fortunately the Italian government has caught up with them and took them to court to get some antiquities back, including the Euphronios vase, the $1 million pot that they bought many years ago, by paying $1 million for it and it was clear then I think, certainly clear now that it was looted from Etruria but anyway the Italian government has to some extent caught up with them, as it has with the Getty Museum. And I was asked to give a lecture once at the Getty and I think I rather shocked them by pointing out they were buying all this stuff and they were thereby supporting the looting of antiquities, but they didn't want to be told that at that time and very sadly they went on buying unprovenanced antiquities so that Marion True, their curator of antiquities, was put on trial by the Italian government and I think there were others at the Getty, including the director, John Walsh and the chairman of trustees of the Getty who were very lucky not to be joining her in the dock because I think they shared responsibility for the purchases that were made. But the campaign is far from won in the United States and although the Archaeological Institute of America shortly after 1970 adopted a very ethical policy, and they won't publish unprovenanced antiquities in their journal, the American Journal of Archaeology, but the director of the Metropolitan Museum of Art, Philippe De Montebello goes on quite untroubled and pretends that everything is above board whereas it's clear that the Metropolitan Museum of Art has been continuing to buy unprovenanced antiquities. There was one very clear episode, the Lydian Treasure, when the Turkish government took them to court, and they first of all tried to claim, the Metropolitan claimed that the Turkish government was out of time, but then the Turkish government pointed out that they, the Metropolitan Museum had concealed the circumstances, hadn't displayed the treasure and in the end the Metropolitan Museum had to give that back to the, back to the Turks. And we have many scandals. We have the scandal of the Sevso Treasure in this country, which was bought by the Marquess of Northampton on the advice of the then president of chairman of Sotheby’s, Peter Wilson... Read the full transcript on [https://www.webofstories.com/play/colin.renfrew/62].
More from this channel
-
0:44
David Weatherall - Entering medical school
-
1:33
Katharine Whitehorn - Embodying the 'Sluts' article
-
6:55
KG Subramanyan - Mohandas Gandhi's views on art
-
2:22
Baruch Blumberg - The link between some cancers and viruses
-
5:03
Carl Djerassi - How Picasso sculpture unveiled problems in my marriage
-
6:39
Renato Dulbecco - Three Nobels, just one class
-
2:26
Marek Edelman - Different criteria for measuring the value of human life
-
2:45
Jules Engel - So who is responsible for a great animation?