Sherwin Nuland - Judgement as an ultimate tool of a physician (42/67)
125 views · Published 14 September 2017 · 4:00 · Indexed 6 November 2026
Channel: Web of Stories - Life Stories of Remarkable People · 2017 · Science & Technology
To listen to more of Sherwin Nuland’s stories, go to the playlist: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gnoweXrGs70&list=PLVV0r6CmEsFwS1mg7ZIN3gt8yKmoZ_o_F US surgeon Sherwin Nuland (1930-2014) taught bioethics, the history of medicine, and medicine at Yale University. He was the author of ‘How We Die’, which made ‘The New York Times’ bestseller list and won the National Book Award. [Listener: Christopher Sykes] LISTENER: And the other thing was, I found that I enjoyed being part of a team. And as I went higher in the training programme, a more important part of the team, until, at the very end, when I was in the final year and-a-half, chief residency, I was the leader of the team. And everything depended on me, and I loved the responsibility. I loved the sense that this was my little cocoon. We could talk about anything we wanted to, except during very close concentration parts of an operation, of which, really in most operations, there aren't more than a few, and they might last 10 or 15 minutes, and then you're on to fairly routine kinds of work. So here we were, like a club meeting every time I was in the operating room. And there were girls there, too, the nurses, who had become part of our group. The other great excitement that I've talked about a lot in my life was waking up every morning and realizing you were significantly better than you were the day before; during that internship year it was technically being better. During the rest of the time, it was intellectually being better. It was judgement, which, to my mind, is the ultimate… the ultimate tool of the physician, is his or her judgement. Everything is about judgement. And even the Greeks wrote about this. The first aphorism of Hippocrates ends with the two words: 'judgement is difficult'. They talk about how delusive even your own experience can be. It can lead you astray. The importance of finding the patient's illness at a time when you can still do something about it. And so, they point out that opportunity is fleeting. Experience is delusive and then judgement is difficult. It begins, this aphorism, with the statement that the art, the art of medicine is long, but life is short. So essentially the Hippocratic physicians were saying to you: you're never going to know everything, and here are some of the roadblocks that will be in your way: the difficulty of judgement, the necessity to find this patient at a time when you can still do something about it, and how experience can fool you, whether it's your own experience or, as I learned later, by following the literature closely, it was the multiple experiences that are reported in the literature. When you read a survey of 2000 patients, essentially these are 2000 individuals put into a pool. Essentially, it's the experience of 2000 individual people with individual manifestations of their disease, and it's one of the reasons that, if you follow medical literature for 10 years, you'll find, not infrequently… not frequently, but not infrequently either, diametrically opposed points of view at year number one and year number 10. Because as more… and more people come into the pool, notions change. There are operations, for example, that we did in the 50s and 60s, radical mastectomy is the classical example that we wouldn't dream of doing today, except under very, very, very extraordinary, unusual, circumstances.
More from this channel
-
0:44
David Weatherall - Entering medical school
-
1:33
Katharine Whitehorn - Embodying the 'Sluts' article
-
6:55
KG Subramanyan - Mohandas Gandhi's views on art
-
2:22
Baruch Blumberg - The link between some cancers and viruses
-
5:03
Carl Djerassi - How Picasso sculpture unveiled problems in my marriage
-
6:39
Renato Dulbecco - Three Nobels, just one class
-
2:26
Marek Edelman - Different criteria for measuring the value of human life
-
2:45
Jules Engel - So who is responsible for a great animation?