Why Miracles Prove Nothing (even if they did happen)

2,708 views · Published 17 October 2012 · 11:45 · Indexed 1 November 2026

Channel: Religion, Atheism, Science · 2012 · Education

Watch on YouTube

Even if we assume that there are genuine miracles (which no rational person should believe - see the video response below for why), that STILL does not give us a good reason for thinking God exists. The argument from miracles is a classic example of an invalid argument.

There is simply no way to connect the dots from an unexplained/miraculous event to a universe-creating deity.  There are an infinite number of hypothetical entities or phenomena that could be responsible for unexplained events..for example a being that is very powerful, but not ALL powerful, or very knowledgeable, but not having ALL knowledge.  If someone is going to advance one supernatural or paranormal explanation for an exceptional event, they have to be willing to consider every other explanation as well. The question is: how can one possibly compare all these different explanations and determine which is correct? How can one reasonably support the idea that something occurred because of an undetectable god rather than human telepathy, ghosts, or something else?

Invoking a god basically means invoking an invisible, mysterious, undetectable entity that causes things to happen via unknown means.  It does not lead us to better understand the event or our universe, and should therefore be rejected as an explanation.  

Bottom Line: The ultimate cause of miraculous events will remain unknown unless we can inquire into the nature of the "causer" itself.  We can't do this when it comes to miracles because **all we actually have are the unexplained events!**  There is simply no reason to prefer a god over aliens, ghosts, leprechauns, or any other hypothetical entity (or phenomenon) as the cause of unexplained events. Without an actual god to examine, all we have is "unexplained event X" and a BARE ASSERTION that a god is responsible for it. But the assertion is not justified. The dots remain unconnected. So even if unexplained events called 'miracles' do happen, they prove nothing.

Thanks to SisyphusRedeemed for the original uploads.  Please subscribe to his channel for more great videos!  http://www.youtube.com/user/SisyphusR...

More from this channel