Investigative Report: Alarming Failure Part VII
104 views · Published 10 June 2013 · 3:22 · Indexed 27 October 2026
Channel: WLOS News 13 · 2013 · News & Politics
Concerned citizens got a chance to speak out after a News 13 investigation found safety issues in Buncombe County schools. Last month we reported district workers were not pulling the required permits for work on electrical and fire safety issues for years. County officials say taxpayers could be on the hook for tens of thousands of dollars and thats the reason some voiced their concerns at Thursday night's school board meeting. District officials have maintained schools are safe because the Fire Marshal inspects them twice a year. Despite this, county inspectors are finding many serious safety issues that were never reported. Superintendent Tony Baldwin was apparently not in the mood to speak with News 13 at Thursday night's school board meeting. As our cameras approached him he motioned for a security officer who told investigative reporter Mike Mason, Sir, you're going to have to leave you can't do that right here okay? After Mason reminded district officials that cameras are allowed inside public meetings, they let News 13 back inside. Dr. Baldwin announced he had finished his investigation into issues News 13 exposed involving permitting problems. Last month, News 13 found maintenance workers were not pulling the required permits or doing inspections for work involving electrical and fire code issues for years. As a result, Maintenance Director Greg Fox and his electrical supervisor, Scott Emory, are now being investigated by the state. Dr. Baldwin addressed the board stating, I have found no evidence of any intentional wrongdoing by either individual based upon the understanding, and I repeat the understanding, that existed at the time between our county inspections department and our school system. Baldwin says permits were not required for small jobs but Buncombe County's Director of Permits and Inspections, Matt Stone, said permits were indeed required for at least 45 work orders we gave him last month. As a result, his department is now inspecting all 40 schools and he's uncovered major problems such as electrical panels that were not up to code and overloaded breakers. Stone told News 13, You don't want a situation where it could heat up to a point where it wouldn't trip, so it's a potential fire hazard. News 13 found violations dating back to 2006 and even though the Fire Marshal inspects schools twice a year he never noted those violations. Now taxpayers could be on the hook for tens of thousands of dollars to get these issues up to code. Retired school electrician, John Payne, is the one who blew the whistle saying Scott Emory told him and other workers not to pull permits as a way for the district to save time and money. For weeks News 13 tried speaking with Emory and was able to finally confront him last night. Mike Mason asked him, I just need to know, did you tell contractors or anybody not to pull permits? Dr. Baldwin then interjected saying, He doesn't want to speak. Mike Mason then addressed Dr. Baldwin asking, You did your investigation, did you ever ask him if he told people not to pull any permits? At that point Dr. Baldwin motioned for a security officer to intercede. The officer told Mason, Sir, you're going to have to leave, you can't do that right here okay? You've got to leave come one. You gotta leave sir, I want you out of here. Although district officials are remaining tight lipped, concerned citizens got a chance to speak up during the public comment section of the meeting. Retired Buncombe County school teacher, Linda Humphries, said, The board is negligent, you should have called for an external investigation into this permitting and inspection situation. Dan Hale is the father of two students in the school system. He addressed board members stating, Mike Mason found work orders that should have been permitted as confirmed by Matt Stone, how many more will there be? How many years back will this go? Another concerned citizen said, I feel sorry for the board with liability issues that may lie ahead because of the irresponsibility of your Superintendent with safety issues. Former school maintenance worker, Steve Stone, announced, The stuff Mike Mason has come up with is just the tip of the iceberg. So far 22 schools have been inspected. Meanwhile, the state continues to investigate the district's Director of Maintenance, Greg Fox and electrical supervisor Scott Emory. By: Mike MasonFollow Mike on Twitter @mikemason1 Related Links: Investigative Report: Alarming Failures Part I Investigative Report: Alarming Failures Part II Investigative Report: Alarming Failures Part III Investigative Report: Alarming Failures Part IV Investigative Report: Alarming Failures Part V Investigative Report: Alarming Failures Part VI