Aleksander Smolar - The complex relationship between democracy and the Church in Poland (63/201)

164 views · Published 18 December 2018 · 3:04 · Indexed 20 November 2026

Channel: Web of Stories - Life Stories of Remarkable People · 2018 · News & Politics

Watch on YouTube

To listen to more of Aleksander Smolar’s stories, go to the playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLVV0r6CmEsFwlxPLurqAOCrabBgGrqLA7

Aleksander Smolar (b. 1940) is a Polish writer, political activist and adviser, vice-president of the Institute for Human Sciences and president of the Stefan Batory Foundation. [Listener: Vitek Tracz]

TRANSCRIPT: The problem of the relationship between democracy and the Church is complex, namely, democracy assumes that the ultimate 'sovereign' – today’s authorities are very fond of that word and use it often – is the citizen. In other words, the citizen and only the citizen has the right to undertake all fundamental decisions beginning with constitutional decisions and the determination of laws. However, the Church questioned and to this day continues to question this, meaning there are certain norms which no individual has the right to determine as they come from God. This affects the conflict that has always existed surrounding, for instance, the issue of abortion. Today’s hot topics include same sex marriage and other issues of that nature which mainly affect how society functions. At that time, this conflict was very intense; the Church had a strong sense of its own validity and felt triumphant, or, in other words, had an exaggerated conviction that everything Poland has is thanks to the Church. I have to say that people from other camps, so to speak, helped create these myths: that it was the Pope, that his visit to Poland had been the deciding factor... It played an essential role and was one of the factors that influenced the Solidarność revolution and its outcome. In any case, it was also a fascinating time of determining rules which unfortunately to this day have still not been determined. I mean that it seems that Poland is a normal country – well, for now with questionable democratic rules, but a normal country. However, people don’t see that the fundamental rules are still subject to game-playing. This means that successive governments – the government presently in office – change the fundamental rules of social or political life. I was aware of this, and in those instances where it related to the Church, I wasn’t involved. But I was present when it concerned international relations, in negotiations with the Germans, for instance, which were hugely important, and contact with [Mikhail] Gorbachev. My presence in these instances was much greater and formed the background to the conflict with the Foreign Secretary. This did happen.

More from this channel