Marek Edelman - Mystery that exists in medicine (139/145)

1,948 views · Published 11 September 2017 · 4:50 · Indexed 6 November 2026

Channel: Web of Stories - Life Stories of Remarkable People · 2017 · News & Politics

Watch on YouTube

To listen to more of Marek Edelman’s stories, go to the playlist: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wpEJsJK7ur8&list=PLVV0r6CmEsFy9YZLKSE0bbnuUJfcOBFxQ

Marek Edelman (1919-2009) was the last surviving leader of the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising. He had remained in Poland following the Nazi defeat and was active in domestic and international politics while at the same time becoming one of Poland’s leading cardiologists. [Listeners: Anka Grupinska, Joanna Klara Agnieszka Zuchowska, Joanna Szczesna; date recorded: 2003]

TRANSCRIPT: [L] How do you now judge medicine, the huge advances made in every field?

The advances are huge, when they do these sorts of operations where they can separate the brains of Siamese twins, sisters, of course technology has advanced enormously. We need to remind ourselves that the first case of extracorporeal circulation was in the form of cross-circulation. When Lillehei, who developed this system, came to visit us, he said we already have equipment to do this since we'd had to do this via cross-circulation before. Progress has been huge. In some cases, this progress is essential, but if we reduce everything to the point where machines replace people in everything, then machines can often make mistakes. Firstly, as in a laboratory - they do a morphology, press a button and they get the results of blood tests, but they get something different because the machine isn't perfect. What I'm talking about isn't significant, but all of this happens without any guarantee that it's right. You say that coronary arteriography which saves lives - yes, but how often is it performed unnecessarily? This procedure isn't without side effects. An electrocardiogram will show you what's going on but no, this is coming from America where certain financial and technical factors play a role, where technology and equipment are better. If today we say that someone sitting in Los Angeles can perform an operation in Zabrze when the professor there is giving instructions on what to do next, then for me... a human being is reduced to a piece of machinery. Yet that's not the case. Because even though he can see that beating heart on his monitor, he isn't able to assess the whole situation the patient finds himself in, no matter what. Of course, technology helps here and there, and today these indicators are made for tumours to show how the markers are, but so what? All of science is progressing. Today, we know that next to the solar system there's another one, and then another bigger one next to that, then we learn something. But a human being is a completely different creature because it's evolution, evolution, evolution; a chimpanzee has almost the same number of genes as a human being and yet there is this colossal difference, that he thinks, and doesn't. How this happens is a mystery. And this same mystery exists in medicine. A machine is very good but if you look at a patient a machine won't tell you if the patient will live or die. Whereas if you take a look yourself and see that the roof of his mouth has turned black, especially if it's child, then you know that he won't live. This is only an observation and so it's not 100%, it's 90% but that's enough. A machine won't pick this up. The best proof of this was that boy who came from Kazimierz who hadn't been able to join the army because he had a serious heart defect. He'd told the commission that he had a pain, they sent him to have some sort of test, an ultrasound, I think, he came back, his father was very unhappy, he'd been a guerilla fighter, my son, I was healthy, my son was healthy, the army, a heart defect, he was referred to hospital for surgery. And this healthy creature comes in - God grant us all such health - and I say, 'What's wrong with you?' 'I have a heart defect.' He shows me a piece of paper, he's to be operated on. So I examined him and say, 'You know what? The equipment was faulty, you're not ill.' So 3 months went by, they summoned him again, to this day the machine is faulty and they have a new one. So that's that. Those doctors take that machine, write something down and goodbye. This means they don't trust their own judgement. If only the doctor had listened to him, examined him but no one gets taught these things any more today.

More from this channel