Aleksander Smolar - The fraught topic of Polish-Jewish relations (168/201)
286 views · Published 20 December 2018 · 4:21 · Indexed 20 November 2026
Channel: Web of Stories - Life Stories of Remarkable People · 2018 · News & Politics
To listen to more of Aleksander Smolar’s stories, go to the playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLVV0r6CmEsFwlxPLurqAOCrabBgGrqLA7 Aleksander Smolar (b. 1940) is a Polish writer, political activist and adviser, vice-president of the Institute for Human Sciences and president of the Stefan Batory Foundation. [Listener: Vitek Tracz] TRANSCRIPT: I had a similar conversation here – it was my first one – Tadeusz Mazowiecki came to Paris and gave a lecture at the Pallottines – the Pallottine Fathers – after which I had an appointment with him, he rang me. He came to us and spoke at length – it was fascinating, very interesting. I had many more friends from that circle – the Catholic intelligentsia of various generations. Jacek Woźniakowski was from the older generation and he was a frequent guest and also I visited him often. Jerzy Turowicz – I met him not in Paris but in Oxford at a Polish-Jewish conference, the first one of its kind that I attended. I wasn't even a formal participant, it was just a time when this topic interested me. I went. It was interesting, a very interesting event. The asymmetry between the Polish and the Jewish sides was also interesting. On the Polish side, there was the cream of Polish intelligentsia with great names like Czesław Miłosz, Leszek Kołakowski, Władysław Bartoszewski. Ryszard Bender, who was an unsavoury character, was there, too. He was part of the nationalist wing of the Catholic intelligentsia. Later, following '89, he played a nasty role – I don't even know if he's still alive. He was a professor in KUL – the Catholic University of Lublin – he was an unpleasant individual. I think there were some eminent professional historians there, too, all of the ones I've mentioned – Bartoszewski was a historian but he was more of a populariser. Then there was Kieniewicz, too – on the Polish side these really were the top intellectuals. Not so on the Jewish or the Israeli side – they were experts, experts specialising in Jewish history, Polish history, the history of Polish Jews. So you could see from this that for the Poles, it was a moral issue, it was an intellectual and a moral issue in some sense – a question of nationality on account of tragic and very convoluted Polish-Jewish relations particularly during the war or immediately after it. For the Jewish or Israeli side, this was the past – it was the past. Polish-Jewish relations. There were almost no Jews left in Poland. There was a handful and I don't remember if there were any Polish Jews among the active participants. I presume there were but right now, I can't remember if there were. In any case, this had been arranged for the Jewish and Israeli participants by Antony Polonsky, an eminent Oxford historian who later moved to the States and he was an expert on Jewish history. I don't know if this struck anyone else, but it struck me very much that you could see this was a totally different issue when it was seen from two sides. For Jews, it was history, the past – it was to do with the past. It was, of course, also a moral issue. I remember that some very bitter words were used, which weren't purely historical, descriptive, in the comments the Jews made about the Poles. You could see that for the Poles, this was a painful issue.
More from this channel
-
0:44
David Weatherall - Entering medical school
-
1:33
Katharine Whitehorn - Embodying the 'Sluts' article
-
6:55
KG Subramanyan - Mohandas Gandhi's views on art
-
2:22
Baruch Blumberg - The link between some cancers and viruses
-
5:03
Carl Djerassi - How Picasso sculpture unveiled problems in my marriage
-
6:39
Renato Dulbecco - Three Nobels, just one class
-
2:26
Marek Edelman - Different criteria for measuring the value of human life
-
2:45
Jules Engel - So who is responsible for a great animation?