Results of Evidence Room Audit Released
101 views · Published 12 August 2014 · 2:52 · Indexed 10 November 2026
Channel: WLOS News 13 · 2014 · News & Politics
Nearly three years after an audit of the Asheville Police evidence room, the District Attorney releases the results.
That audit has been kept under wraps by the D.A., pending the outcome of a criminal investigation. News 13's Frank Fraboni was there when the 3,000 page document was released.
Reporters were invited to go through the thousands of audit pages Thursday afternoon at the District Attorney's office. D.A. Ron Moore says these pages shine light on what led to the criminal case against former Evidence Room Manager, Lee Smith.
"We found what appeared to be where someone had cut open exactly where the flap went, apparently taking the drugs out and they resealed it and they tried to put tape back over it in the exact same place, so it would appear it had not been tampered with," says Moore.
Smith pled guilty this week to stealing drug evidence that turned up missing in 2011. How that could happen is documented in these pages, pages that talk about the record-keeping disaster that was the Asheville evidence room. The audit by Blue Line Systems outlined the problems. "A confusing and in some places, non existent shelf and location numbering system. A software package that is difficult to use and understand, and failure to utilize an exact and specific location numbering system "
"Without taking every single item out of that property room and going through every piece of paper, you can't say that it is not there," says Moore. Moore says the $175,000 audit's purpose was to find evidence of any criminal wrongdoing. It revealed Smith was stealing drugs from sealed evidence packets, his fingerprints found on tampered packages that were placed back on the shelves empty.
"This was not just counting and seeing if items were there. It was looking to see if there was evidence of a crime and if there was a crime, evidence of who might be the perpetrator," says Moore.
As for missing guns and money, the audit shows items were missing. But Moore says it also reveals that record keeping was so poor. Items were later located somewhere else, seized and forfeited to authorities, destroyed or returned to their owner, but never properly documented in the evidence room computer. "There's no evidence that Lee Smith stole any guns or money. The evidence was what he was prosecuted for which was taking drugs out of closed cases. And I think that's what we have," says Moore.
Some cash and guns are still unaccounted for, but Moore says until there's a complete inventory of all 60,000 items, there's no way to know whether they're missing, destroyed or misplaced, in an evidence room that clearly is in disarray.
Related Links:
Evidence Room Audit
Evidence Room Sentencing
Evidence Room Scandal Sentencing
_______________
Follow WLOS on social media:
WLOS ABC 13 News on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/News13/
WLOS ABC 13 News on Twitter: https://twitter.com/WLOS_13
WLOS ABC 13 News on Instagram: https://instagram.com/wlos_13
Subscribe to WLOS on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/user/ABC13Channel/?sub_confirmation=1
Listen to AnchorMOMS, the Podcast:
https://wlos.com/news/anchormoms/anchormoms-the-podcast
Watch more top local news stories: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kk8Ge6UXHJs&list=PLkVbaoT-aYbIvnEpR0Ct5QQQqYaORUSUH
For all of the day’s top local and national news, visit http://www.wlos.com
Watch our live newscasts and other live video at https://wlos.com/watch
Have a news tip? Send it directly to us:
Email us: [email protected]
Call the Newsroom: 828.684.1340
WLOS ABC 13 News serves the Asheville, NC area and the rest of western North Carolina and Upstate South Carolina. We keep our audience informed through local news, weather forecasts, traffic updates, notices of community events, sports and entertainment programming since 1954.