François Jacob - The precaution principle, ethics and cloning (77/77)

243 views · Published 10 August 2017 · 2:38 · Indexed 27 October 2026

Channel: Web of Stories - Life Stories of Remarkable People · 2017 · Science & Technology

Watch on YouTube

To listen to more of François Jacob, go to the playlist: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bBSb6rIJ0Sg&list=PLVV0r6CmEsFxcUFA9rIQwdpd7L7ayJnKk

François Jacob (1920-2013) was a French biochemist whose work focused on understanding how genes are controlled. In 1965, he shared the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine with Jacque Monod and André Lwoff for his contribution to the field of biochemistry. [Listener: Michel Morange; date recorded: 2004]

TRANSCRIPT: [MM] Today we often talk about the precaution principle. What do you think about it?

Not much, because I think it's mainly a way of protecting governments, to be sure that they protect themselves from their own possible mistakes. But I think that there needs to be some precaution, but making a principle of it isn't reasonable. Some say that it could threaten scientific knowledge. Partly. You can freeze everything with that if you want. Because obviously, by precaution, you particularly can't touch anything, it could blow up in your face. It sort of leads to ethical questions.

[MM] You wrote quite a lot on genetics, the place it can have, or the bad use that can eventually be made of genetics in regards to racism, etc. What do you think about it? Is there a risk that genetics be used for that purpose?

There's a risk and the Nazis showed it to us, that's clear. All that has been around for a while. The fact of separating people according to their abilities, etc., it's ancient history. It was pushed to such an extent by the Nazis, but it's ancient history. Which reappears more or less everywhere, as soon as the Nazi story clarifies itself.

[MM] And do you not think that modern technologies, in vitro reproduction, and all that, brings up a particular problem, or provides an additional risk?

I think so. But I think we need to be careful. Meaning that we shouldn't be doing just anything. But I do think that everything can't be frozen, but we need to be careful. And that we need to be careful not to do just anything. I was thinking of, what is it called... duplication...

[MM] Cloning?

Cloning, cloning... It has... this sort of hanging threat. And what I especially found incredible, the day we started speaking of cloning, the ukase of politics saying: never, never. We are banning it. But cloning a man doesn't seem like something that will be done tomorrow, so I don't see the point of it.

[MM] No? Or for some people with very...

Yes, lunatics are everywhere. But the importance of cloning people still doesn't seem very obvious.

More from this channel