Marek Edelman - The era of coronary arteriography (134/145)

1,922 views · Published 11 September 2017 · 4:38 · Indexed 12 November 2026

Channel: Web of Stories - Life Stories of Remarkable People · 2017 · News & Politics

Watch on YouTube

To listen to more of Marek Edelman’s stories, go to the playlist: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wpEJsJK7ur8&list=PLVV0r6CmEsFy9YZLKSE0bbnuUJfcOBFxQ

Marek Edelman (1919-2009) was the last surviving leader of the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising. He had remained in Poland following the Nazi defeat and was active in domestic and international politics while at the same time becoming one of Poland’s leading cardiologists. [Listeners: Anka Grupinska, Joanna Klara Agnieszka Zuchowska, Joanna Szczesna; date recorded: 2003]

TRANSCRIPT: Then one day, with a successive patient, Moll decided and we did this procedure. That means, not we but Moll did it. We attended, and by the following day the patient had recovered. We did 12 operations like this. Of these 12, two people died and 10 survived in good health yet there was a lot of opposition to our work. I don't know what to say, but when something new is introduced everyone is against it. In this case, there were other factors involved, no coronary arteriography was needed and they're expensive to do, so lots of things played a role here. But we did these 12 operations and we had the satisfaction. Then we found out that 30 years earlier someone called Beck in America had had the same idea and had performed a similar operation but had done it differently, and it had not been a success so it had been abandoned. It hadn't been successful because the idea... I don't want to go into the details but it was too low and there was no pressure, but the idea was there. Later, when Moll went to a conference in Germany and presented this, the audience gave him a standing ovation, their reaction was extraordinary. But he came to Poland and was persecuted here. As if this wasn't enough, I think 12 or 15 cases were treated in this way and then the era of coronary arteriography was introduced. We were opposed to this because when they were being performed, initially, they were quite dangerous, we wondered how we could get by without them, and we discovered these marks in the electrocardiogram, these spikes but it's not important, which showed where the changes were. And a few operations were performed in this way. We came into the operating theatre, the patient's thorax had been cut open, and Moll's assistant asks, 'Where's the obsruction?' So we say, 'Here, here and here.' He opened up, removed the sheet covering the heart, touched it with his finger... unfortunately, it's true. He was an opponent of this so we didn't have an easy life but we did everything and it's somehow credited. Years later it turned out that in Leningrad a student of Lewin's had written a handbook on how to diagnose changes in the coronary arteries without an arteriography. Then in America there's someone called Engelman who also wrote something similar but because a coronary arteriography is very expensive, today we have stents, which is a completely different matter and so there's no need for an arteriography, but I think it was devised and performed fantastically. We wrote about it in a book called 'Heart Attack'.

[L] Two editions.

What?

[L] Two editions.

We were successful and this is described and we demonstrated it in Warsaw at Cardiology Society. I didn't speak well, I wasn't brief enough but Moll said later - we didn't get much applause - Moll said you couldn't get much applause because they understood everything straight away. If they can understand it, it means it's worthless, you didn't drop any names - that way it would have been good. We had some success there, then Elżbieta died, Aga went to live in Algeria. She was frightened of the secret police and left for Algeria.

More from this channel