Former OSU Football Star Jailed, Accused of Shooting Kettering Man

619 views · Published 2 October 2012 · 2:38 · Indexed 4 November 2026

Channel: Dayton 24/7 Now · 2012 · News & Politics

Watch on YouTube

DELAWARE -- A former Ohio State Football star is behind bars after a road rage incident. Police said James Stillwagon is accused of shooting at a man in a pick up truck. One bullet grazed the pick-up driver's head.                 The shooting happened Sunday, on East William Street, near US 23, in  Delaware, Ohio.  Delaware is about 85 miles northeast of Dayton. Richard Mattingly has two staples  in his skull, and has lost the hearing in his right ear,  but he says he is extremely lucky."It is one of those things.  I feel like I got a second chance. My dad said, a half an inch, and you wouldn't be here," Mattingly told ABC 22/FOX 45 reporter Chelby Kosto.       Mattingly was driving  near Delaware visiting his dad when his transmission went out, making his pick up truck stop and start suddenly. Mattingly said it angered the man behind him riding a motorcycle.  "The first chance I had  to pull over,  I did, and I let him pass. But rather than continue on with his life, he decided to try to kill me."Mattingly said the biker pulled out a gun and fired several shots at   him and and his pick up truck. He said one of the bullets grazed his  head. "He  told me, 'You're dead, you're dead!' He treated it like it was a type of game, like he was gonna win no matter what." The alleged gunman was  identified as James Stillwagon. He played  OSU football from 1968 to 1970. Stillwagon, who wore number 68,  was an All-American as a junior and senior, and won the "Outland" trophy and was the first-ever winner of the "Lombardi award."He was also one of the so-called "Super Sophomores of 1968," guiding the Buckeyes to an undefeated season and a national championship. He inducted into the Buckeyes Hall of Fame in 1991. Stillwagon was in court Monday,  facing felony assault charges. His bond was set at 50,000.         "I feel bad," Mattingly said. "A great guy like that, couldn't get past what happened and it had to turn into that. Rage took over."

More from this channel