The Psychology Behind Political Hypocrisy | From the Archives

3,130 views · Published 18 July 2017 · 10:41 · Indexed 27 October 2026

Channel: JoshTolley · 2017 · News & Politics

Watch on YouTube

How can someone passionately support a political idea that appears to produce the opposite of what they say they want?

In this episode from The Josh Tolley Show archives, Josh takes a critical look at progressive politics and what he sees as contradictions between political intentions and real world outcomes.

His argument raises a larger question that reaches beyond any single political ideology.

Why do people sometimes defend positions even when confronted with information that challenges them?

Politics isn't always driven by a careful comparison of policies and results.

Identity matters.

Emotion matters.

The groups we belong to matter.

And once a political position becomes connected to someone's identity, changing that person's mind can become much more difficult than simply presenting another set of facts.

Josh examines several ideas associated with progressive politics and argues that some policies can produce unintended consequences that conflict with the goals of the people supporting them.

But are those contradictions unique to progressives?

Or is this something virtually everyone can do when politics becomes part of personal identity?

Years later, research into motivated reasoning and partisan bias gives us an interesting way to revisit the argument.

People on different sides of the political spectrum can evaluate the same information differently depending on whether it supports or threatens what they already believe.

So perhaps the bigger question isn't simply why the other side gets things wrong.

It's whether any of us recognize when we're doing the same thing.

From The Josh Tolley Show archives.

More from this channel