Design Rights - Construction Documents and Services - Architect Registration Exam A.R.E. Live

1,714 views · Published 18 February 2016 · 4:57 · Indexed 10 November 2026

Channel: Black Spectacles · 2016 · Education

Watch on YouTube

Download the Mock Exam:
http://bksp.es/cds-mock-exam-2016 

ARE Prep powered by Black Spectacles-
blackspectacles.com/courses
Mike's Recommended Resources to pass the ARE:
http://blackspectacles.com/blog/books-need-to-pass-are-exam-resources 

Mike: Number six. All right, "After the house is finished, the developer client uses the drawings to build another three houses. They said they paid for the design, therefore they should be able to reuse it. Are they right?" And answer A is yes, because they paid for the design. Answer B is no, because they have no rights to the design. Answer C is there is no copyright on architectural design. And answer D is yes, but only if they have specifically stated so in the original contract. 

There is a basic issue on the typical contract that shows up a lot, and people misunderstand this one a lot. Architects generally get it pretty well, but clients misunderstand this a lot. The basic issue is the architect always has the copyright, unless it's specifically delineated in the contract that they don't have the copyright. So the people who would do that, for some reason often federal and people federal projects always require the copyright, I don't know what that's about, but the people where it really makes sense would be like franchisees. If you're doing something for McDonald's or for In-N-Out Burger, or something like that, they want to own all the design, because it's a huge part of their business, their marketing and all of that, and they can't let other people have that. 

So there are places where it totally makes sense that the owners would take over the copyright. And they would have to do that in the contract. They would actually scratch out part of the contract and write in that the owner of the copyright will be the client. But the typical contract, the architect always retains copyright. But, and this is a big but, the big but is, the client has full rights to use the design for that project, in that location. So if a client has paid you for a design, even if there's a dispute along the way, even if the project never goes to completion but you had a bunch of drawings that did get done and they paid you for those drawings, they have the right to use that design for that project, in that location. 

They can have another architect come and take it over and continue on the design, because they have the rights to that. You have the copyright, but they have the rights to use it for that project, in that location. What this project is saying is, okay, so they've done a house and now they're doing three more. So answer A, yes, because they paid for the design. That's not a reasonable answer because that's not enough information. Just because they paid for one design doesn't mean they paid for doing these other three houses in different locations just by saying three more houses. 

Those are clearly in three other locations, so that clearly doesn't work, so it's definitely not A. And then B, no, because the owners have no rights to the design. Well that's not right. We just said they have full rights to use the design. They don't have copyright, but they have full rights to use the design in that location, for that project, so it's not B. And then C, there is no copyright in architectural design. We just said the architects retain the copyright. So the answer is D, yes, they can do it, but only if in this original contract it's been written in, that they are going to reuse these designs. 

And typically what you would do on that situation is you would have a contract price for your fee, and then a reuse fee. So maybe you might charge, I don't know, let's say, $10,000 for the original one, and then $1,000 each for each additional time they use it, something like that. You would build that into the original contract, if they didn't do that on the original contract, then they're in the wrong and you could actually potentially sue them.

More from this channel