Uri Avnery - My concept of a Palestinian state has its proponents (140/315)

87 views · Published 31 July 2017 · 3:43 · Indexed 31 October 2026

Channel: Web of Stories - Life Stories of Remarkable People · 2017 · News & Politics

Watch on YouTube

To listen to more of Uri Avnery’s stories, go to the playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLVV0r6CmEsFw4EQRLZvAoreWVLWLJDNaI

Uri Avnery (1923-2018) was an Israeli writer, journalist and peace activist. He was editor-in-chief of the weekly news magazine "HaOlam HaZeh" and founded the Gush Shalom peace movement. [Listener: Anat Saragusti; date recorded: 2017]

TRANSCRIPT: Well, it was clear that he didn't accept that [idea]. And then also I suggested… I went back to my old proposal to establish a Ministry for Affairs of Peace. I suggested it to him again. He told me: 'There is a Ministry of Foreign Affairs which is responsible for that'. It ended in nothing. Good spirit, but nothing concrete yet I have these three things on record: the article in "Daf", the article in "HaOlam HaZeh" and this conversation with Levi Eshkol. There were probably other people who thought about it but never publicised it. Arik Sharon claimed years later in a conversation with me that he himself had been inclined towards the same thing. The idea was: we needed to return to the previous situation. No one had dreamed that Israel could hold onto the territories, it had never entered our mind, it was a ridiculous idea. We had just a few years ago gone through the Sinai Campaign. President Eisenhower and President Bulganin had forced us to draw back to the last grain of sand in Sinai, so to think now suddenly that they would leave this to us? The question was not whether to return it, the question was to whom it should be returned? And the general consensus was: 'What do you mean? To Jordan!' Once again the idea was that if perhaps we return it all to Jordan, maybe it would be possible to 'steal' East Jerusalem, to keep East Jerusalem, or to return it to the Palestinian people, this is what we demanded. And as strange as it seems, this idea of returning it to the Palestinian people was very popular among the top brass of the IDF, the IDF leadership most of whom were rather logical people compared with politicians. And the IDF did a simple calculation that I also expressed: return it to Jordan, which means more time – one country from Tulkarm to the outskirts of Baghdad, a large Arab country that can easily bring all the Arab armies from around: Syria, Iraq and Saudi Arabia. In contrast the Palestinian state would inevitably be a small country, it would be possible to conquer it in a day or two, that would always be easy and it was therefore attractive. I know that Talik, who was a very important man in the IDF, an important general, and all sorts of other generals quietly championed this idea.

More from this channel