Richard Brown -Explaining Consciousness and its Consequences

1,777 views · Published 29 December 2010 · 42:34 · Indexed 16 November 2026

Channel: onemorebrown · 2010 · Education

Watch on YouTube

A talk given at the CUNY cognitive science speaker series in 2010. If the higher-order thought theory explains phenomenal consciousness by our awareness of mental qualities, it is puzzling why conscious thoughts would have no phenomenology. The talk works through Rosenthal's views on mental qualities, concepts and the content of higher-order thoughts, considers ways of avoiding the conclusion, and ends with a reply to Ned Block's argument about empty higher-order thoughts.

0:00 Introduction
2:17 Rosenthal and the explanatory gap
4:18 The argument
7:53 Mental qualities and qualitative character
11:43 Unconscious perceptual thoughts
13:56 Applying concepts changes experience
16:02 Peeling away higher-order thoughts
20:01 The content of the higher-order thought
22:02 Seeing blue consciously for the first time
24:10 The modest higher-order view
25:03 Starred concepts
28:04 Is the response ad hoc?
31:55 A qualitative character for thoughts?
36:02 Asserting and believing
37:49 Addendum: Block's argument
41:22 A causal-historical account of higher-order concepts

Richard Brown argues that David Rosenthal's higher-order thought theory is committed to thoughts being phenomenally consciousness

More from this channel