Judge Nadel retires after 32 years on common pleas bench

309 views · Published 7 January 2015 · 3:33 · Indexed 29 October 2026

Channel: LOCAL 12 · 2015 · News & Politics

Watch on YouTube

YOUR DESCRIPTION HAS REACHED THE LIMIT OF CHARACTERS ALLOWED AND WAS CUT. HAMILTON COUNTY, Ohio (Jeff Hirsh) -- The longest-tenured judge in Hamilton County is about to step down from his position.   

Common pleas Judge Norbert Nadel is retiring, effective Wednesday, Dec. 31. Local 12 takes a look back at Nadel's long career, from low-profile cases to those followed in the region and, yes, even across the entire country.

The Tracie Hunter trial kept Hamilton County common pleas court Judge Norbert Nadel in the public eye for weeks. It was not the first time. And it kept him in the judicial system for even longer.   

"Actually, I‚„ve been in this room for 32 years," said Judge Nadel.

After graduation from Chase Law School, Nadel served as an assistant Cincinnati city attorney, assistant U.S. attorney, Hamilton County municipal court judge, and domestic relations court judge. All that before being appointed to common pleas court in 1982 and getting returned to the bench every election since.

Judge Nadel shared, "And it just seems like yesterday when I walked in. The only difference in this room, and it's almost 32 years to the day, there was a red carpet here. But everything else is pretty much the same, and I've tried to keep it that way."

Nadel's most famous case, actually one of Hamilton County's most famous cases ever, was Peter Edward Rose versus A. Bartlett Giamatti. Pete Rose against the Commissioner of Baseball in 1989. 

"It was everywhere in the country. And I would get calls, my brother who lives in California would call and say, 'My God, you're on the front page of the Los Angeles Times.'"

Nadel ruled that Commissioner Giamatti was biased against Rose and could not give Rose a fair hearing. While baseball ultimately prevailed against Pete and banned him from the game, Nadel said his ruling was correct, "And if I had to do the same thing 25 years later I would do the same thing."

Of course, not all of Nadel's cases have been front page news. His very first case as a judge, in municipal court, was on whether a dog should be ruled vicious and be taken from its owner.

"I continued the case and said bring in that dog and let's take a look at it. Well the dog came in and licked me. The dog was licking me and couldn't have been nicer. So I dismissed the case and the lady got her dog back," remembered Judge Nadel.

Nadel said consistency is critical for a judge. Keep your standards the same. Sometimes that means giving somebody a long sentence. But sometimes, it means a sentenced person turns her life around and gets a good job.

"And she came in about a week ago and put her arms around me and said, 'Thank you for throwing me a rope, you changed my life and look at where I am today.' And that made me feel good," Nadel said.

Nadel is not retiring because he's had enough. Far from it, Nadel is retiring because a state law does not let judges run for re-election once they're past age 70.

Reporter Jeff Hirsh said, "I remember when Judge Nadel started in this courtroom. I was kind of a cub reporter, and since then I've covered a lot of his cases. Pete Rose, Tracie Hunter and a lot of others. It's hard to believe that after all of these years this name is finally coming off of this door."

Nadel told Local 12, "Oh I'll miss this terribly, oh yes, oh yes. Because it's been a big part of my life for the last umpteen years, the past 4 or 5 decades this has been a part of my life, so certainly I'll miss it."

Nadel is allowed to serve as a visiting judge, filling in when others are on vacation, so he will be able to hear some cases in the future.
       %2

More from this channel