Group calls for iconic sign to be taken down

641 views · Published 19 November 2014 · 1:58 · Indexed 12 November 2026

Channel: LOCAL 12 · 2014 · News & Politics

Watch on YouTube

CARTHAGE, Ohio (Sydney Benter) -- A local car lot's 'big Indian sign' is the target of those who say it needs to come down.

'Where paddock meets vine at the big Indian sign,' that's how people remember the jingle that's been steering car buyers to this car lot for 60 years.

"It's very iconic. It's the Indian on Vine. It's that well-known," said Tod Swormstedt, founder of the American Sign Museum.

Despite its notoriety, or perhaps because of it, there's a push to remove it from the Motor Time car lot. Judy Gibson Combs, who is part Native American, used to live in Carthage and was visiting recently. Surprised to see the sign still firmly planted, she took to the Internet to voice her disapproval. Her friend, Homer Shadowheart, was one of the first people to sign her petition.

"The sign is a caricature and it's an offensive symbol," said Shadowheart.

The signees hope the car dealership takes the sign down. Shadowheart said he realizes there are bigger fish to fry for the Native American community, but he thinks removing the sign would be a step in the right direction.

"No change has ever come by just jumping. It's always been very small steps, so you take small steps to get to the bigger picture," he said.

Shadowheart hopes the dealership has a change of heart, because he says the sign sends the wrong message.

"We don't care about you

More from this channel