030514 CLOSING ARGUMENTS

972 views · Published 6 March 2014 · 40:27 · Indexed 21 October 2026

Channel: SCOTT ENGLE-MONTGOMERY COUNTY POLICE REPORTER- · 2014 · News & Politics

Watch on YouTube

Day three of the Donald Collins hearing started Wednesday morning with Montgomery County  Cold Case Detective Duroy. Defense attorney Tay Bond questioned Duroy as to how long he had been handling the case which he picked up in 2011.

Defense attorney Tay Bond said law enforcement knew about some type of sexual misconduct between Collins and Middleton in 1998. Duroy said it was limited to Collins wanting to see Robbie’s butt.

Bond then started questioning Duroy on the evidence that was destroyed by mistake in 2006. It included 13 items such as a lighter, plastic jug found at the scene, hoses and gage for a boat fuel tank. Also included were cigarette butts which were found in the woods. He told them no DNA was done on the items and several used the trails to smoke so it was possible it wasn’t tied to the case.

Back in 2006, it was believed to have just been an assault case and the Statute of Limitations had run out. A destruction order was signed by a judge and the items were destroyed.

It wasn’t until 2011 when a deposition was taken by a legal team as part of a lawsuit filed against Collins by the Middleton family that Robbie Middleton implicated Donald Collins in the burning of him and also admitted to Collins raping him two weeks earlier.

During three days of testimony this week by 25 witnesses, prosecutors presented what they believe is new evidence to try Collins for murder, evidence they say was not known when Middleton was attacked in 1998.

“The state’s investigation was thorough then,” said attorney E. Tay Bond. “They did not have enough evidence then, and they don’t have enough to go forward now.”

This new evidence included statements from one of Collins' cousins, Heather White, who testified Collins had confessed to her that he and another boy had been responsible for the attack. A man who was 8 years old when he was sexually assaulted by Collins in a separate incident testified Collins threatened to burn him like Middleton if he told anybody what happened. Collins was convicted of sexual assault in this separate case.  He is also awaiting trial in San Jacinto County for a sex offender failure to report. This is the third time he has been charged with the same.

Collins, took the stand Wednesday morning to say that he was invoking his Fifth Amendment right to be protected from incriminating himself.

"I will remain silent," said Collins, who is being held on a $1 million bond.

Bond suggested this destroyed evidence could have helped clear Collins.

Bond has argued the case shouldn't be transferred to adult court because in 1998, state law said a juvenile had to be at least 14 years old for a capital felony offense case to be transferred to adult court. The law was changed in 1999 to lower the age to 10.

Prosecutors allege the crime of murder did not take place until 2011, well after the law was changed. Bond said the law can't be retroactively applied to Collins.

“The state’s investigation was thorough then,” said attorney E. Tay Bond. “They did not have enough evidence then, and they don’t have enough to go forward now.”

Judge Hamilton will decide Thursday morning if the case should be transferred to adult court. If it is, the Montgomery County District Attorney will present it to the  Montgomery County Grand Jury. If he is then indicted the case will be handled by the Montgomery County District Attorney’s Office for prosecution.

More from this channel