100614 DON COLLINS CHANGE OF VENUE

594 views · Published 6 October 2014 · 3:16 · Indexed 12 November 2026

Channel: SCOTT ENGLE-MONTGOMERY COUNTY POLICE REPORTER- · 2014 · News & Politics

Watch on YouTube

After hearing arguments last Friday as to why the Donald Collins, who is accused of lighting  Robert Middleton on fire, should have a trial somewhere besides Montgomery County a decision has been made. It appeared Judge Hamilton had a long weekend researching case law on the subject. Monday morning after almost twenty minutes of addressing the court on the case law she researched granted the change of venue motion requested by Collins defense attorney Tay Bond.  A meeting will take place on Tuesday in Judge Hamilton’s chambers between both the defense team and the prosecution. She hopes in that meeting to find three locations favorable to both to hold the January trial. With those three locations Judge Hamilton will need to contact those counties to determine if they will allow it to be held there. A county can deny the request. Judge Hamilton will then make a decision. 

The change stemmed from what Judge Hamilton stated was all the media coverage since the 1998 incident in which Don Collins was said to have poured a flammable liquid on 8-year-old Robert Middleton and light him on fire. He was burned over 99% of his body. 

In addition Judge Hamilton set a October 29th date to hear two motions filed be the defense. 

The first is to suppress a custodial statement and the second is to suppress a deposition given by Robert Middleton before he died. 

The custodial statement states Collins was interrogated in 1998 by Montgomery County Sheriff’s Office detectives under poor audio recording quality and signed a written statement that he neither wrote himself, nor had the sufficient educational ability to understand its contents.

Bond is also contending the introduction of the statements as “dying declarations” is improper,” because the testimony was made more than a decade after Middleton suffered his injuries.

More from this channel