Judge makes decision on electioneering

60 views · Published 23 October 2014 · 2:47 · Indexed 8 November 2026

Channel: LOCAL 12 · 2014 · News & Politics

Watch on YouTube

COLD SPRING, Ky. (Angela Ingram) -- Political signs liter both sides of Route 27 for high visibility to passing drivers, but the ones at Campbell County Auto Body, across from polling place First Baptist Church, have been repeatedly removed. 

John Russell, the owner of the auto shop, said "The problem that we ran into is that on Election Day, we're right across from the church which is a polling place. There are signs on both corners and people standing on both corners holding up signs, but our signs were maliciously broken and torn down." 

Russell's business has been in that location for more than three decades. He says he allowed candidates to put the signs on his private property to show support. Russell said he tried to work with officials on the issue.

"I understood that there was a limit on the distance," Russell said. "I even came in early that day at 7 a.m. and tried to take them down. I know the polls open at 6:00, and they had already come and broken them down."

So, Russell's lawyer sued, attacking Kentucky's election nearing statute. 

Brendan Voelker, Russell's attorney, said "First and foremost there is private property. I don't know why anyone in government would think you could pass a law that would allow you to trespass on private property and remove political signs." 

A federal judge found the entire law unconstitutional, saying it violates the 1st and 14th amendments. His ruling effectively stops officials statewide from enforcing that law.  

"Whenever property owners, taxpayers and voters can stand up against government for intrusion, especially on your private property, that's a good day for everyone," Voelker said.  

The judge said part of the problem with how the Kentucky law was written is that it didn't have a private property exemption. Many other states and commonwealths do.

Follow us on Twitter @Local12 and LIKE us on Facebook for updates!

More from this channel